SATs

Year 6 SATs don’t make children unhappy, says study

Researcher says findings counter 'conventional narratives', but critics question research based on 2012 data

Researcher says findings counter 'conventional narratives', but critics question research based on 2012 data

Year 6 SATs have little effect on children’s happiness and wellbeing, a new study suggests.

John Jerrim, from University College London (UCL), said the findings provided an “important counter to conventional narratives” that the tests could have a “serious negative impact upon children’s wellbeing”.

However, critics have questioned the findings, which are based on data from 2012. There have been major changes in curriculum and tests since then.

Jerrim, the report’s author, said more research was needed to “better understand both the positive and negative effects these tests have on young people, especially in light of the challenges teachers and pupils have faced throughout the pandemic”.

SATs
Jerrim

But he concluded there “does not seem to be strong enough evidence to support key stage 2 tests to be scrapped on wellbeing grounds”.

The peer-reviewed study analysed data from about 2,500 year 6 children in England, where tests are carried out, and other UK countries that do not run tests.

A release of the report’s findings said there was “little difference” in the wellbeing and happiness levels reported by children, regardless of whether they took tests or not.

Among those that did SATs, there was “no significant change” in how they felt about themselves, their school or family life in the weeks around tests.

Nearly 25 per cent of children in England said they felt unhappy about their schoolwork before the tests compared with 28 per cent for children in the rest of the UK. This figure did not significantly increase or decrease in the weeks before and after testing.

Findings challenge views of staff on SATs

The findings, which can be read in full here, challenge the views of school staff. A 2019 UCL study, conducted for More than a Score, which campaigns to scrap SATs, found four in five headteachers thought the tests had a negative effect on pupils’ wellbeing.

A 2018 National Education Union (NEU) survey of 1,200 primary teachers found nine in ten believed the tests were “detrimental to children’s wellbeing”, causing “harm” and “stress”.

The union’s report included examples of children having nightmares and making themselves ill so they did not have to attend school.

Kevin Courtney, the joint general secretary of the NEU, dismissed the new study, which is based on 2012 data from the Millennium Cohort Study (MCS).

“Unfortunately, the researchers have drawn conclusions about the future of primary testing based on analysis of the regime almost ten years ago.”

A “radically changed” curriculum meant it would be “much more helpful to study the impact of more recent testing”.

A press release accompanying the report said reforms since 2012, while “unlikely to undermine key findings”, could affect pupil wellbeing “if the importance attached to these tests has increased”.

Responding to Courtney’s comments, Jerrim said the mental health debate was a “fairly long-running argument”, adding: “Show us the money – let’s get some high-quality unbiased evidence that’s not funded by an interest group and let’s see what the data says.”

He said the tests played a “fundamental role feeding into school accountability metrics and our findings suggest they should continue in their current form for the foreseeable future”.

Latest education roles from

Internal Quality Assurance Employability and Distance Learning

Internal Quality Assurance Employability and Distance Learning

Capital City College Group

Distance Learning Tutor

Distance Learning Tutor

Capital City College Group

Event Support Team Leader

Event Support Team Leader

MidKent College

E-Sport Technician

E-Sport Technician

MidKent College

Digital Technician

Digital Technician

MidKent College

Student Welfare Officer

Student Welfare Officer

MidKent College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: Discover Leader Apprenticeships with NPQs

Recent cuts to NPQ funding, as reported by Schools Week, mean 14,000 schools previously eligible for scholarships now face...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How do you tackle the MIS dilemma?

With good planning, attention to detail, and clear communication, switching MIS can be a smooth and straightforward process, but...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How can we prepare learners for their future in an ever-changing world?

By focusing their curriculums on transferable skills, digital skills, and sustainability, schools and colleges can be confident that learners...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Inspiring Education Leaders for 10 Years

The 10th Inspiring Leadership Conference is to be held on 13 and 14 June 2024 at the ICC in...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

SATs

Scaled scores for 2024 key stage 2 SATs announced

Department for Education publishes marks pupils need to meet the 'expected' standard

Schools Week Reporter
SATs

SATs 2024: Schools face results ‘queue’ system

Leaders face 'enduring same frustrations as music fans struggling to get concert tickets', says union

Samantha Booth
SATs

Primaries fail to opt out of SATs – but say they won’t be testing

FOI data reveals just 7 per cent of primary schools opted out of receiving KS1 papers

Samantha Booth
SATs

Capita loses £180m SATs contract to exam board Pearson

Schools faced ‘significant frustration’ during outsourcer’s first year, with thousands of papers going missing and wrong marks awarded

Samantha Booth

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 Comments

  1. I whole heartedly agree that SAT’s test’s do more harm than good. As a parent I can verify the level of stress placed upon my child to get high marks during his SAT’s was so astounding he wasn’t sleeping, his anxiety hit the roof and he wet himself more than once. This level of stress took me to rethink my role 1, as a parent and 2, how I could prevent this for my next child. My desicision was to remove my children from the school system after numerous failures not just the stress placed upon my son. Now I home educate 3 children while 2 attend secondary school. Honestly I believe home Ed is the way forward, there is less pressure on our children to make schools look good. We were never told SAT’s were optional and we could opt out until it was too late.

  2. Laura B

    What a lot of bull! They do cause stress upset and disruption I have seen kids brake down and cry, I have seen the change in kids from happy to stressed out and fed up

    This should not be what their last year of primary should be….they start teaching to the sats in year 4 and 5 now it’s disgusting

    End of year mini projects could demonstrate their understanding and ability in subjects and make it fun …. WE DO NOT NEED SAT TESTS