Schools

Three ideas to boost teacher pay (without breaking the bank)

With ministers refusing bigger pay rises, we asked the policy experts what they could do instead

With ministers refusing bigger pay rises, we asked the policy experts what they could do instead

The current stalemate between the government and education unions over teacher pay does not look like it will resolve itself soon, with ministers unlikely to offer more money this year.

While an immediate solution will need be found, poor recruitment and retention make it a problem that is unlikely to go away.

So what are the solutions that might be palatable to unions and ministers? Schools Week asked the policy experts…

Pay shortage-subject teachers more

The prospect of paying teachers in shortage subjects more than others came up in crunch talks this week, and union leaders are less than impressed.

Dr Mary Bousted, the joint general secretary of the National Education Union, said that paying staff differently depending on their subject would “make the situation even worse”.

“All that teachers will hear is that I’m doing all this work, holding up society, because all the support services around me have gone. And I’m now being told that somebody else with a different subject will get more than me. That’s a terrible narrative for where the profession is now.”

But a 2017 study by Dr Sam Sims, from UCL’s centre for education policy and equalising opportunities, found a 5 per cent salary supplement for shortage subjects could resolve shortfalls. It was also cheaper than recruiting more teachers.

Sims told Schools Week that the graduate market had changed, citing the example of physics graduates becoming app developers.

“The extent to which you can get paid more as a physics graduates outside teaching…has expanded. The gap has grown more than the same gap for somebody who’s a history graduate, for example. And this is probably going to carry on.”

However, Sims said the only way to solve the strikes issue in the shorter-term was to pay teachers more, and warned unions would oppose any move towards differentiated pay by subject, because they “could never make it fly with their members”.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said the gap between public and private sector pay was now “less favourable to the public sector than at any point in the past 30 years”.

Teachers work fewer hours for the same pay

In 2019, the government’s workload survey found the average teacher worked for just under 50 hours a week. One in four worked more than 60 hours a week.

Jonathan Simons, a former Downing Street adviser under Gordon Brown and David Cameron, pointed to New Labour’s 2003 agreement with unions to reduce workload through changes to teachers’ contracts.

Among other things, the agreement brought in planning, preparation and assessment (PPA) time as a contractual entitlement.

“An updated version of that agreement that reduced working hours – effectively giving teachers more money per hour (as government would present it) could be an alternative to pay increases – would address one of the major drivers of teachers leaving the profession.”

Iain Mansfield, a former DfE special adviser and now head of education at the right-wing think tank Policy Exchange, said ministers, unions and Ofsted should “work together to reduce workloads” rather than focus on pay.

The government is also understood to be keen to look at the increasing expectations on schools, often resulting from cuts to other public services, and the “role of schools in the social contract”.

A source cited examples, including primary schools providing toilet training and secondary schools policing local parks at the weekend.

More money upfront, less in pensions

The idea of allowing public sector workers to take more money upfront rather than squirrel it away in their pensions has been floated a number of times.

Robert Colvile, the head of the CPS think tank and co-author of the 2019 Conservative manifesto, wrote recently this would give workers a pay bump while “easing the long-term pressure on public finances”.

Gillian Keegan, the education secretary, has talked about the generosity of teachers’ pensions when she has been interviewed about pay. Employers currently contribute 23.68 per cent.

James Zuccollo, the director for school workforce at the Education Policy Institute, told Schools Week that the ongoing dispute meant it made sense “to explore new policy solutions”.

“While many will value the security the existing pension plan gives, there are likely some who would prefer to take more salary home instead.”

The IFS has also mooted it as a solution. A study found nearly half of public sector staff received employer pension contributions of at least 20 per cent in 2021, compared with just 2 per cent of private sector employees.

Zuccollo said several US states had offered teachers a “different balance between pay and pension”, with up to a third of teachers opting for the flexibility “suggesting some teachers do prefer to take more salary, particularly when they are young”.

However, the unions are likely to resist any changes.

Latest education roles from

IT Technician

IT Technician

Harris Academy Morden

Teacher of Geography

Teacher of Geography

Harris Academy Orpington

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Exams Assistant

Exams Assistant

Richmond and Hillcroft Adult & Community College

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Solihull College and University Centre

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

It’s Education’s Time to Shine: Celebrate your Education Community in 2025!

The deadline is approaching to nominate a colleague, team, whole school or college for the 2025 Pearson National Teaching...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: An Apprenticeship Success Story

Last year’s NPQ funding cuts meant that half of England’s teachers faced costs of up to £4,000 to complete...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Embedding Formative Assessment: not just a box-ticking exercise but something long-term and meaningful for all

Our EFA programme has been proven to help schools achieve better GCSE results, as evidenced by the EEF. Find...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Building capacity in family support to tackle low school attendance 

Persistent and severe school absence impacts children, families, and communities—especially in disadvantaged areas. School-Home Support’s Attendance Support and Development Programme...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Schools

Cease and desist: Trust supports staff to sue online trolls

Provision for staff sickness cover will be broadened to cover defamation

Jack Dyson
Schools

Head scores victory as Google agrees to delete school reviews

Tech giant says all school reviews will now be deleted because of ‘consistent off-topic and harmful’ comments

Rhi Storer
Schools

‘I don’t remember it being this bad’: Teachers reveal scale of Labour’s school-ready promise

Survey reveals mismatch in expectations between teachers and parents over what 'being school ready' means

Rhi Storer
Schools

Big academy trust given £1.5m government loan to stay afloat

A 24-school trust racked up seven-figure losses after paying for iPads for staff and pupils

Jack Dyson

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment

  1. Elisabetta Nucifora

    I think workers should be warned against accepting more salary and less pension: old age comes unexpectedly and when it comes there is no chance of putting the clock back and saying: oh gosh, I was wrong. When you are retired you need more in terms of assistance, medications, support, even special food, which can be covered only if you have a nice pension to bank on.