Ofsted: School rated ‘good’ after ‘inadequate’ rating legal challenge

The 'only change' since the first inspection 'was the inspector', Queen Emma primary school chair says after new rating

The 'only change' since the first inspection 'was the inspector', Queen Emma primary school chair says after new rating

11 Sep 2023, 10:30

More from this author

Ofsted has rated a school good after overturning its recent inadequate judgment

Ofsted has rated a school as ‘good’ after removing a previous ‘inadequate’ report from its website amid a legal challenge.

Queen Emma Primary School in Cambridge was inspected in October and given the lowest rating over its leadership and management and safeguarding.

But a new inspection took place in June, with inspectors finding that all areas of the school were good and safeguarding was effective.

The report has now been published on the school’s website.

Sean Lang, chair of governors at Queen Emma, told the BBC that the “only change [since the first inspection] was the inspector”.

“Had we not put up such a fight against the original finding we would still have an inadequate rating,” he added.

The school had previously launched a legal bid against the watchdog in a dispute over evidence for its initial findings.

It had lodged an application with the High Court for a judicial review of the October report, as well as formal complaint with Ofsted.

Though Ofsted did not uphold the complaint, the school requested an internal review over the way it was handled.

Back in June, the inspectorate said during the review it became “apparent that we had not considered concerns about the personal development judgment sufficiently”.

This “cast some doubt over that particular judgment”, leading Ofsted to remove the report from its website and promise to reinspect the school.

Ofsted prompted by legal fight

The move was highly rare. Ofsted latest annual report shows that of complaints about 747 inspections of all settings in 2022-23, just five led to overall effectiveness judgments being changed.

The watchdog has been criticised over inconsistencies within its school inspections.

Following its initial inspection, Queen Emma had accused an inspector of taking away confidential information about children, resulting in a breach of data security.

A statement released by the school said “no substantive changes” were made within the school between the two inspections.

It added that the new report “fully vindicates” its legal challenge to the original report.

“It shows that Ofsted can carry out its functions professionally and supportively; however, the school’s experience of Ofsted inspection over the past year shows that this cannot be guaranteed in every case.”

In an impact statement as part of the school’s complaint to Ofsted, headteacher Sarah Jarman said the experience had “shattered every piece of self-belief I had”.

The new report sets out that leaders had established an “effective” safeguarding culture, “underpinned by a reliable and well-understood system for reporting and sharing concerns”.

Staff had “impactful training” and felt “empowered” to fulfil their safeguarding roles, meanwhile pupils enjoyed “being part of a diverse and welcoming community”.

Inspectors added that the school “is a place for learning and for making friends”.

Ofsted has been contacted for comment.

More from this theme


School wasn’t gaming as it can do ‘pretty much anything’, court hears

High court judge criticises Ofsted for 'entirely erroneous understanding' of 'gaming' as city technical college downgraded to ‘good’

Lucas Cumiskey

Ofsted to examine how SEND pupils are prepared for adulthood

Inspectors will visit a 'small number of areas' to look at a 'particular aspect of SEND in-depth'

Lucas Cumiskey

Ruth Perry: Reading council to survey heads’ wellbeing and challenge rogue Ofsted inspections

Actions follow coroner report into the death of headteacher Ruth Perry, but sister says it shows council has ‘not...

Lucas Cumiskey

Ofsted orders review into wiped evidence claims

Schools Week revealed how technical glitches force inspectors to re-record inspection evidence, sometimes from memory

Freddie Whittaker

Ofsted’s digital inspection system glitch revealed

Electronic evidence gathering system has faced technical issues since it was launched in 2019

Freddie Whittaker

Ofsted: MPs want ‘nuanced’ alternative to ‘totemic’ judgments

Parliament's education committee also also calls for less frequent, more 'in-depth' inspections

Lucas Cumiskey

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *