Schools

Guidance on supporting trans children in schools: 7 key findings

Unofficial guidance from unions and sector bodies aims to help schools meet their legal duties while supporting trans children

Unofficial guidance from unions and sector bodies aims to help schools meet their legal duties while supporting trans children

11 Nov 2022, 15:59

More from this author

Unofficial guidance on supporting trans pupils has been published by education unions and organisations to help schools prepare for new DfE guidelines

New sector guidance on provision for trans pupils suggests schools may need to provide both gender neutral and single-sex toilets and that uniform policies should be as “inclusive as possible”.

The unofficial advice for maintained schools and academies in England has been jointly published by school leaders’ unions ASCL and the NAHT, the National Governance Association, the Institute of School Business Leadership, the Chartered College of Teaching and the Confederation of School Trusts.

Ahead of anticipated new official guidance from the Department of Education, the briefing is an attempt by the organisations to help leaders get to grips with the “context of recent developments” and the wider law.

“The rights and protection of transgender people are currently contested and rapidly developing areas of law,” the guidance states.

“Set against this backdrop, decisions about how to support transgender pupils can be complex and sensitive.”

Here are the main recommendations for schools.

1. Schools may need gender neutral and single-sex facilities

According to the guidance, to meet regulatory requirements for all pupils, schools may need to provide both gender neutral and single-sex facilities.

This is because it could be unlawful for schools to permit pupils of one sex to use the toilet facilities provided for pupils of the other sex “unless those facilities were each in a single lockable room intended for use by one person”.

School premises regulations stipulate that toilet facilities for boys and girls aged 8 or over must be separate. The organisations said they had received “clear independent legal advice” that the equality act does not override this.

The act protects people against unlawful discrimination because of protected characteristics including gender reassignment (where a person is proposing to undergo, is undergoing or has undergone a process to reassign their sex).

The briefing refers to legal sex – the biological sex recorded on a person’s birth certificate. People aged 18 and over can change their legal sex by obtaining a gender recognition certificate.

2. Names and pronouns should ‘not be undertaken lightly’

The guidance around names and pronouns is less clear.

It states than in accordance with the human rights act, schools should “normally work”, with the agreement of parents, “towards respecting the wishes of pupils to be the people they wish to be”.

This includes being known by a different name or addressed with different pronouns.

But it points to a finding of the Cass Review Interim Report that “affirmation and social transition are not neutral acts” and could have a “significant impact” on a pupil’s psychosocial functioning.

The review also found that “doing nothing” for a child in distress was also “not a neutral act”.

As a result, the unofficial guidance suggests social transition “should not be undertaken lightly” and some schools may wish to take a “more cautious approach” .

It notes, however, that staff deliberately and repeatedly misgendering pupils could amount to discrimination because of the protected characteristic of gender reassignment.

While case law is still developing, it advises school to make it clear in codes of conduct for staff and pupils that all speech must be “courteous and respectful at all times” and that they must show “mutual respect and tolerance” for those with different beliefs about gender identity.

3. Gillick-competent pupils can socially transition at school without parents knowing…

Where children wish to transition socially at school without the knowledge of their parents, “the law is clear” that their views “should prevail” if they are Gillick-competent, the guidance states.

Gillick competency is used in medical law to decide whether a child is able to consent to their own medical treatment.

But the briefing admits that assessing Gillick competence in this area is “far from straightforward” and is likely to require legal advice.

Consideration will need to be given to whether a pupil will be able to understand the implication of the decision.

4. …but schools can support ‘open conversations’ with parents

Even if a child is deemed to be Gillick-competent, the guidance says this does not prevent schools from working with them in an “appropriate and sensitive way” to help them understand the implications of their decision not to inform parents.

Examples of this include supporting pupils with a planned disclosure which they can choose the timing of, as opposed to an accidental disclosure “which may otherwise be inevitable”.

In some cases, the guidance adds, it might be appropriate for trusted staff to support pupils to “open the conversation” with their parents or carers.

5. Schools can teach that ‘gender critical’ beliefs are protected

DfE’s relationships and sex education (RSE) statutory guidance for secondary pupils states that pupils should be taught the “relevant legal provisions” about gender identity, but does not stipulate which provisions.

The guidance says these could include the fact that gender reassignment is included among the protected characteristics within the equality act.

But it also suggests pupils could be taught that the same act protects single-sex spaces, services and sports and does not necessarily entitle transgender people to access them.

Meanwhile, it adds RSE lessons could also cover that gender critical beliefs, as well as the belief that gender is a matter of self-identity, are currently considered protected beliefs.

6. Uniform policies should be ‘as inclusive as possible’

Elsewhere in the briefing, the organisations draw on 2021 non-statutory uniform guidance from the DfE.

It advises that when making decisions about uniform policies, schools should take their obligations under the human rights act and equality act into account and consider the impact on pupils who share a protected characteristic.

The unofficial guidance therefore says that governing bodies should make uniform policies “as inclusive as possible” to accommodate the cultural needs of pupils and to avoid gender stereotyping.

It suggests schools could have a single list of uniform items with regard to the “needs of pupils with different protected characteristics” and permit pupils to wear any item on the list.

But it adds that this “should not involve” the creation of a gender neutral uniform “which requires girls to wear trousers”.

7. Single-sex schools can discriminate on the grounds of sex

Single-sex schools are lawful and can continue to discriminate in their admissions on the ground of sex, the guidance says.

It adds that a school’s single-sex status would not be compromised if it allowed a current pupil who transitions to remain in the school because they would legally remain the same sex.

But the organisations note that whether it is lawful for single-sex schools not to consider trans pupils of the other legal sex “is more contentious”.

The legal advice they received while drawing up the guidance was that this would be lawful in view of a single-sex exemption in the equality act.

Latest education roles from

Internal Quality Assurance Employability and Distance Learning

Internal Quality Assurance Employability and Distance Learning

Capital City College Group

Distance Learning Tutor

Distance Learning Tutor

Capital City College Group

Event Support Team Leader

Event Support Team Leader

MidKent College

E-Sport Technician

E-Sport Technician

MidKent College

Digital Technician

Digital Technician

MidKent College

Student Welfare Officer

Student Welfare Officer

MidKent College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: Discover Leader Apprenticeships with NPQs

Recent cuts to NPQ funding, as reported by Schools Week, mean 14,000 schools previously eligible for scholarships now face...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How do you tackle the MIS dilemma?

With good planning, attention to detail, and clear communication, switching MIS can be a smooth and straightforward process, but...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How can we prepare learners for their future in an ever-changing world?

By focusing their curriculums on transferable skills, digital skills, and sustainability, schools and colleges can be confident that learners...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Inspiring Education Leaders for 10 Years

The 10th Inspiring Leadership Conference is to be held on 13 and 14 June 2024 at the ICC in...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Schools

‘Children are our future and it’s for them that Tim dedicated his life’ 

Hundreds gather to remember the late Sir Tim Brighouse

Samantha Booth
Schools

Birmingham withdraws schools from £100m IT system

Heads were unable to make financial plans as glitches left them waiting months to learn the size of their...

Jack Dyson
Schools

Hinds says ‘all schools’ restrict phones, and 5 more key findings

Schools minister also says the 'option' of statutory mobile phone guidance remains

Freddie Whittaker
Schools

CST calls for policy changes over ‘unsustainable’ parent complaints

Academy body says rise in complaints is putting 'significant pressure on school leaders’

Jack Dyson

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 Comments

  1. Glenys Richards

    As a Granny of two and great aunt of many, and a retired nurse/midwife, I think some of this trans conversation is confusing? When I delivered babies they were boys or girls and we decided that gender by the genitalia the baby was born with. I also delivered very few babies of indeterminate sex due to neither male or female identifiable genitalia. These children, along with their parents were referred to medical and psychogology specialists for future tests support and guidance. Also gay people and children have been part of our rich mix of the human race and many people I have worked with have been gay and also many patients. I hope the teachers of trans are medically trained to advise and guide these confused children about there hormone confusing young bodies and that they have a degree in child psychology. Child abuse comes in many forms and I feel strongly that those talking of such sensitive intimate subjects to minors have been suitably equipped to do so.

  2. My daughter was going on a USA trip with her school this year from the UK. Ater paying £1700 I received a letter from the school stating that my daughter would be sharing a dorm with a bioloigal boy (transgirl). Clearly at the point we wrote to the school and pointed out our daughter sex based rights under the equality act 10, with thanks to the SEX MATTERS website. e school then took two weeks to agree the biological boy would now be in his own dorm and away from all of the girls dorms. Since then the school have added a Trans Policy (which they do not have to do). This document again states that any residential trip will be discussed with the trans pupil and parents and the school will accomidate them! Yet, there is no discussion with any of the other pupils or their parents until they are all paid up. Plus not all parents and pupils knew about the letter we were sent. I am now awaiting a meeting with the head after being ignored for the last few days! I will not let this go!