News

Nearly a third of academy transfers down to government intervention over failures



Almost a third of all academies that were transferred to new trusts last year were moved because of direct government intervention following failures.

Data released for the first time today reveals that the Department for Education stepped in 80 times in 2017-18 to directly enforce re-brokerage, either through transferring schools or closing sponsors.

This is the first time this data has been published, and it does not include academy transfers for any of the years prior to 2017-18. Official statistics released in July showed that 255 academies moved to another trust in 2017-18, an increase of 30 per cent from 196 the year before, but did not include the reasons for the moves.

The figures show 61 of these schools were transferred ‘due to intervention’. Another 22 academies were re-brokered because their sponsor closed. However, just three of these are listed as voluntary closures, while 18 are classed as ‘voluntary closure following intervention’. Another one, Millfield Community Academy Trust, is listed as an ‘intervention closure’.

The new data also shows that 172 academies have been classed as being re-brokered under a ‘transfer initiated by the trust’. Single-academy trusts can choose to join multi-academy trusts, and 103 of these transfers were standalone academies. However, concerns have been raised that single-academy trusts are finding it increasingly difficult to remain independent.

Between September 2013 and July 2018, 628 academies moved to another trust. This is equivalent to 3.3 per cent of all open academies in England. The data shows the DfE has spent almost £23 million on grants for academy transfers, but as this does not include deficit funding the total cost of the moves is likely to be far higher.

Those made to move by the government include Grindon Hall Christian School in Sunderland and Haltwhistle Community Campus Upper and Lower schools in Northumberland, which all joined the controversial Bright Tribe Trust between April and June 2017.

Less than a year later, in February 2018, the trust announced it would re-broker four of its five schools in the north of England, including the three transfers. Schools Week revealed Bright Tribe was closing down entirely in July.

The DfE also directly intervened to move academies previously run by the Perry Beeches Academy Trust, with five of the failed trust’s schools moving to the Core Education Trust.

 



Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 Comments

  1. 18 transfers are classified as sponsor closures following an intervention. This implies the rebrokered academy was inadequate and the sponsor decided to jump ship. However, this may be unfair. Folkestone Academy, for example, was judged good in October 2015 before it transferred to Turner Schools.
    Accounts for Folkestone Academy (renamed OLDFAAT) for year ending 31 August 2017 show trustees issued an ‘invitation’ to Turner Schools to support the academy. The academy ’s original sponsor, Sir Roger de Haan retired as chair when two trustees from Turner Schools, a newly-established multi academy trust (MAT), joined the OLDFAAT board.
    So what triggered this intervention when Folkestone Academy wasn’t inadequate? It appears it may have been because it was classified as ‘coasting’ in January 2017.

  2. 172 of the rebrokered academies are classified as having initiated their own transfer. But this might not quite be true. For example, 18 academies were transferred from The Hillary Trust, Jefferys Education Trust, Edwin Jones Trust and The Ridings Trust to Hamwic Education Trust. This mass transfer was triggered by the DfE changing the rules on umbrella trusts. Such trusts would no longer be able to oversee a number of small trusts as Hamwic had been doing. Theoretically the transfers may be said to have been initiated by Hamwic but this was in response to a change in DfE regulation.