Academies

MPs demand answers over academy probe transparency rowback

Public accounts committee 'concerned' decision to publish investigation summaries 'hinders transparency'

Public accounts committee 'concerned' decision to publish investigation summaries 'hinders transparency'

The influential public accounts committee has demanded answers from education officials after Schools Week revealed a promise to publish academy scandal investigations had been ditched.

The Department for Education has published 27 academy investigation reports since 2012 under a promise to be “fair and transparent about how public money is spent”.

But in October, an “outcome” report after an eight-year investigation into the Lilac Sky Schools Trust was published.

Unlike full reports, the “outcome” publication had few details, totalling just three pages. Full published reports are normally at least ten pages, with some as many as 30.

Government was berated by the Public Accounts Committee in 2019 for not being “sufficiently transparent about the results of inquiries into concerns” about financial management and governance of trusts.

One of its commitments following the criticism was to publish the results of investigations within two months of the work being completed.

But Schools Week revealed the DfE has quietly changed its policy to now only publish investigation “outcomes”.

‘Concern investigation changes hinder transparency’

Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, PAC chair (pictured above left), has now raised “concern that the [publication] changes hinder transparency and do not align with the view of the committee” from its 2019 report.

He has demanded an explanation from DfE permanent secretary Susan Acland-Hood in a letter published Thursday.

Acland-Hood has been asked to set out how the department “considered transparency against other factors, such as timeliness, when changing [its] guidance to ensure evidence-based decision”.

He also wants assurances on how officials will “ensure sufficient information is available to the sector to understand gaps in practice and learn lessons with just investigation outcomes published”.

The additional information will “allow my committee to consider whether publication of investigation outcomes, rather than reports, on a timely basis sufficiently complies with the substance of the Committee’s 2019 recommendation”.

The DfE said previously its commitment was still met by publishing outcome reports.

Doing so “enables the investigation team to publish the pertinent information from these reports without an overly protracted” legal process, such as allowing those criticised to provide a response.

This rule, known as the Maxwellisation process, has “historically led to significant delay in publishing investigation outcomes”, the DfE added

The change also enables the government investigation team to “spend more time on its core function of investigating fraud and financial irregularity across the academy trust and further education sectors”.

The DfE was approached for comment.

Latest education roles from

MGL – Childcare

MGL – Childcare

Barnet and Southgate College

MGL – Health & Social Care

MGL – Health & Social Care

Barnet and Southgate College

Centre School Administrator

Centre School Administrator

South Thames College

Work Based Tutor – Light Vehicle Paint or Body & Repair

Work Based Tutor – Light Vehicle Paint or Body & Repair

Bolton College

Contract Compliance Officer

Contract Compliance Officer

Barnet and Southgate College

Exams Officer

Exams Officer

Southwark College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Bridging the Skills Gap: Recognising Self-Awareness and Wellbeing

ASDAN renews the six core skills at the heart of its learner-led approach and development of personal effectiveness qualifications.

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Cybersecurity in Education: Building Trust and Integrity

Schools, academies, colleges and, universities in particular, are expected to provide state-of-the-art facilities, blending advanced technology with academic excellence...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Ensuring Learning Never Stops: Portakabin Supporting Schools Affected by RAAC

In recent months, the discovery of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) in over 230 schools across England has presented...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Text-based programming tools for young learners

The Raspberry Pi Foundation’s Code Editor helps make learning text-based programming simple for children aged 9 and up. Learn...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Academies

Brighton trust to close after ‘GAG pooling’ controversy

MAT at centre of first 'GAG pooling' strikes will transfer schools to other trusts

Jack Dyson
Academies

Labour’s ‘act of vandalism’ bill risks pay cuts for 20k teachers, claim Tories

Critics of Labour's academy freedom reforms pile in as schools bill set to be debated by MPs

Freddie Whittaker
Academies

Loss of academy freedoms could harm improvement of toughest schools – CST boss

Leora Cruddas also says government 'must help us put a stop to all attempts by those who seek to...

Freddie Whittaker
Academies

Children’s wellbeing bill to enact sweeping academies reform

Draft law would let councils open schools again, end automatic academisation of failing settings and make academies follow national...

Freddie Whittaker

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *