Tutoring

Ministers plan to publish school-level tutoring take-up – and Ofsted will check

Government wants to 'improve transparency' and boost take-up, but sector leaders fight the plans

Government wants to 'improve transparency' and boost take-up, but sector leaders fight the plans

Exclusive


Ministers plan to name and shame schools not using tutoring cash under a new push to “improve transparency and support uptake” of the flailing flagship scheme.

However, Schools Week understands the proposals are being strongly challenged by sector leaders, who fear it will push failure of the scheme on to schools.

Ofsted would also check schools’ tutor figures under the plans.

Government figures show two in five schools have not used the National Tutoring Programme this year. 

Holding schools to account to rescue a failing programme may hit the target but misses the point

Education secretary Nadhim Zahawi will write to all schools “early” next week unveiling new plans to “improve transparency and help identify and support uptake” of tutoring among schools.

The intention was outlined in an email sent to schools from the Department of Education yesterday afternoon.

Schools Week understands the government wants to publish school-by-school data showing their tutoring take-up based on the allocations they received. 

The intention behind the plans is that they would allow both parents and Ofsted to check if schools were spending their tutoring cash. The drive behind the move is to improve take-up at those schools that have not used their tutoring cash.

It is believed the allocations published will be the grant funding issued under the school-led tutoring route, introduced this year. Publication of the data would likely be at the end of the academic year.

Schools were given £579 million to organise their own tutoring this year, with another £65 million dished out earlier this year.

Approach risks ‘pushing’ tutoring failure onto schools

However, sector leaders are pushing government to drop the plans. One source said it would push the failure of the government’s heavily criticised flagship tutoring scheme on to schools.

Provider Randstad had its contract to run the scheme axed recently, as revealed by Schools Week.

Latest data shows just 887,521 tutoring courses have been started since September, leaving the government well off its promise of two million courses by the end of this year.

tutoring Covid absence attendance leadership Omicron schools academy trusts white paper
Whiteman

However, three quarters of the courses have been under the school-led tutoring pillar. The other two routes – using an approved tutoring provider, or an academic mentor – are way behind schedule.

Paul Whiteman, chief executive of school leaders’ union NAHT, said it would be the “wrong way to rescue the government’s original failure to deliver an effective tutoring programme”.

“School leaders will use tutoring well if allowed to make professional judgments. Holding schools to account to rescue a failing programme may hit the target but misses the point. 

“Further accountability measures may drive compliance, but will not drive excellence.”

Catch-up efforts hampered by Covid

School catch-up efforts have been hampered by conditions out of their control.

Covid disruption has left leaders constantly firefighting to keep classrooms staffed – in turn exacerbating struggles to find tutors as supply options dwindle.

Government could use data from two mandatory collections for the school-led tutoring cash. 

tutoring
Peacock

The first is the school census, undertaken once a term. Schools must record all pupils who have received tutoring through the grant this year. 

The second is an end-of-year statement from the Education and Skills Funding Agency, released in June. 

Dame Alison Peacock, chief executive of the Chartered College of Teaching, warned that “naming and shaming is never the right way to go. I feel a knee-jerk response is unhelpful typically. Schools are trying to do the best they can with very limited resources and trying to support youngsters who’ve missed out during the pandemic,” she said.

The Department for Education said it will be announcing more details next week and so have nothing further to add.



More from this theme

Tutoring

Zahawi apologises for bank holiday tutor league tables announcement

But unions still concerned about new 'accountability measure'

Samantha Booth
Tutoring

DfE boss: Tutoring league tables ‘not a stick to beat schools with’

Susan Acland-Hood also reveals ongoing discussions about Randstad's contract, which ends this summer

Freddie Whittaker
Tutoring

‘Blame game’ as Zahawi moves to publish tutoring take-up

The government will name and shame schools over tutoring use and report data to Ofsted

Samantha Booth
Tutoring

Zahawi accused of breaking own wellbeing pledge with tutoring letter

Heads' unions say bank holiday memo also contravenes the DfE's own workload commitments

Samantha Booth
Tutoring

School tutoring ‘league tables’ will be published this autumn

School-level take-up data will also be shared with Ofsted as ministers seek to name and shame schools over take-up

Freddie Whittaker
Tutoring

Nearly 50k tutors to be trained under new £18m National Tutoring Programme

More details on overhauled catch-up scheme revealed

Samantha Booth

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.