Exams

Fine exam boards for GCSE errors, education MPs demand

Exams regulator Ofqual will 'consider regulatory action'

Exams regulator Ofqual will 'consider regulatory action'

Ofsted safeguarding Spielman catch-up exams committee

Exam boards should be fined for errors in exam papers this year, the influential chair of the education select committee has urged.

Schools Week has reported on several mistakes in exam papers and advance information in the first summer exam series since the pandemic began.

Robert Halfon said it was “deeply regrettable” that “due to an apparent lack of due care and attention, some exam boards have issued papers that ignored the advance information or contained errors”.

In a letter to new education secretary James Cleverly on behalf of the committee, the Conservative MP said: “This negligence on the part of exam boards would have resulted in pupils facing unnecessary distress and anxiety during this already stressful period of high stakes summer exams.

“In addition, these errors risk undermining public confidence in the exams system.”

Halfon urged exams regulator Ofqual to “levy financial penalties” on boards whose papers contained errors. Fines should be “proportionate to the scale of the errors, and significant enough to act as a strong deterrent,” he added.

He also said exam boards must issue full marks for questions with errors and “ensure this decision is communicated to schools and pupils without delay”.

AQA has already done this for its GCSE physics paper which included a question on a topic specifically ruled out in advance information.

Halfon lists four examples of problems – three attributed to AQA, which includes an A-level law paper including a 30-mark question on a topic not in advance information.

He also points to an AQA GCSE geography paper which, as revealed by Schools Week, featured a question that included a coloured map and key that were inaccessible to colour blind pupils.

Edexcel has also apologised over an error in its GCSE Geography B paper 3 which labelled Gabon as the Democratic Republic of Congo on a map of Africa.

Halfon said: “While errors in exam papers, and the issuing fines in response, are not
unprecedented, we believe the consequences of such errors are more profound
this year, given the educational disadvantage pupils faced during the pandemic.”

Dr Jo Saxton, Ofqual’s chief regulator, has previously acknowledged that the mistakes caused “distress”.

In a letter to the committee earlier this month, she said of the 354 specifications with advance information, “only a handful of errors have emerged”.

“Our first priority is to regulate on behalf of students, and accordingly we expect the awarding organisations to make sure students’ interests are protected and the integrity of the qualification is upheld.

“We will closely monitor the awarding process to make sure that students are
not disadvantaged compared to those taking the same qualification with another exam
board.

“Regulatory action is, of course, also in scope and is something we will consider
once the immediate interests of students are protected.”

In 2018, OCR was fined £175,000 after a mix up over Romeo and Juliet characters. Then in 2019, AQA was fined £350,000 – the largest penalty ever handed out by Ofqual – for “serious breaches” of re-marking rules.

The Joint Council for Qualifications, which represents exam boards, said: “Exam boards work hard to make sure their materials are error-free – and, of the many thousands of question papers and advance information documents produced in another unusual year, there have only been a very small number of errors.

“In these cases, exam boards have quickly taken appropriate action to put things right and make sure students aren’t disadvantaged.”

More from this theme

Exams

AQA staff to strike on A-level and GCSE results days, Unison confirms

But union claims of results disruption branded 'scaremongering' by schools minister

Amy Walker
Exams

Teachers fear 2022 exams will widen attainment gap

'Impacts of the pandemic on education are far from over,' new research finds

Samantha Booth
Exams

AQA staff plan second walkout days before A-level results

Exam board accuses Unison of trying to disrupt grading meetings

Samantha Booth
Exams

Minister promises to get tough on exam board mistakes – again

Ofqual could take 'regulatory action', but previous ministerial criticisms and watchdog fines do not appear to be preventing problems

Tom Belger
Exams

Teachers back digital exams in principle, but school tech not yet up to scratch

Research by exam board AQA finds substantial barriers to digitising exams in England, despite support for the model

Freddie Whittaker
Exams

‘Stressful and exhausting’: Ofqual report exposes teacher grade woes

Survey also shows over half of teachers felt pressured to change their grades last year by either leaders or...

Samantha Booth

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.