Schools

Failed contractor’s £45 million schools to be demolished and rebuilt

But one of the schools says work will take four years, as ministers take legal advice over recouping costs from collapsed construction company

But one of the schools says work will take four years, as ministers take legal advice over recouping costs from collapsed construction company

5 Dec 2023, 10:56

More from this author

Buildings at three almost-new schools will be demolished due to safety concerns

Three schools built by the same construction company at a cost of £45 million will be demolished and rebuilt over safety concerns, as the government seeks legal advice on recovering costs from the failed firm.

But one of the schools has confirmed works will not be completed for four years, while another is still unsure of the location for new buildings.

Sir Frederick Gibberd College, in Essex, Haygrove School, Somerset, and Buckton Fields Primary School, Northampton, were told in August to close their almost-new buildings constructed by Caledonian Modular.

Surveys found buildings at the three schools, closed in August, could not withstand “very high winds or significant snowfall”.

Academies minister Baroness Barran has now confirmed that the Department for Education (DfE) will fund the rebuilding of the schools.

“We have continued to prioritise face-to-face learning during this time and to help schools through this transition phase, we are providing each school with high quality, long term temporary accommodation,” she said in a statement.

Barran thanked parents and pupils for their “patience” over the last five months, and said the new buildings would have “great indoor and outdoor facilities”.

Contracts worth £38 million for the Sir Frederick Gibberd and Haygrove buildings were awarded to Caledonian Modular in 2019 under the DfE’s £3 billion “modern methods of construction” framework.

Under its contract, Caledonian Modular – which went into administration in March 2022 – led design, planning and installation of the schools. 

The firm was also awarded a £6.5 million contract for building works at Buckton Fields.

Following its collapse, two schools it had been contracted to build in Cornwall were demolished before construction was completed after the government identified “defects”.

Surveys carried out at the DfE’s request earlier this year showed buildings at the three schools closed in August could not withstand “very high winds or significant snowfall”.

Temporary buildings still not in place

Closures meant a staggered start to term at the schools, with some pupils being temporarily transferred to other school sites.

Buckton Fields pupils have been educated at Pineham Barns Primary School, which is also run by Preston Hedges Trust.

Pupils will move into “interim buildings” at the Buckton Fields site in February.

The trust’s CEO, Paul Watson, said while it “certainly would not have ever wanted to be in the position” it is currently in, “we are pleased there is now certainty over the existing school building”.

Year 7 pupils at Sir Frederick Gibberd have been temporarily educated at another school ran by The BMAT Education Trust, while its GCSE pupils have been using other schools for specialist science and DT subjects.

BMAT said that a “full suite” of temporary classrooms would open from April, while the permanent building was not expected to be completed until 2027.

Some Haygrove pupils have been educated in temporary classrooms, with others going to a different school site.

But in a letter to parents on Friday, the school said it was still “engaging” with the DfE on details “such as timescales and the location of the new buildings”.

DfE ‘seeking legal advice’ on recouping costs

Documents filed by administrators on Companies House show the DfE was owed £2 million when Caledonian Modular collapsed.

But there were “insufficient funds” to cover unsecured creditors, which included the DfE.

“We are also reviewing our contracts, and seeking legal advice on how we can recover the costs where that contractor was involved,” Barran has now said.

The DfE said it would launch an investigation into the firm in August.

Schools Week also reported in September that the DfE was yet to find construction companies for four new special schools after two firms contracted to do the work – including Caledonian Modular – collapsed.

It emerged yesterday that a new 210-place primary school in Cheshire, due to open in September 2025, would be delayed by at least a year due to the collapse of a construction firm.

Northwich Guardian reported that Cheshire East Council had warned escalating costs because of the delay could lead to the scheme no longer being affordable.

Latest education roles from

Exams Administrator

Exams Administrator

Bournemouth and Poole College

Management Information and Exams Officer

Management Information and Exams Officer

Capel Manor College

Lecturer (Maths)

Lecturer (Maths)

Bournemouth and Poole College

Chief Operating Officer, Central Region Schools Trust

Chief Operating Officer, Central Region Schools Trust

Satis Education

Admissions Officer

Admissions Officer

South Thames College

Student Services Adviser

Student Services Adviser

South Thames College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Catch Up® Early Years research project has a positive impact on younger learners in Literacy and Numeracy.

Catch Up® has recently concluded a 3-year Early Years research project. The project sought to develop and trial...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

National competition – can your students solve the ocean plastics crisis?

University College London launches fully resourced national schools competition to tackle ocean plastics.

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

EUK Education – helping you inspire, educate, and inform students on STEM and career paths

EUK Education is the new home for all your STEM education and careers needs. Loaded with quality curriculum-linked programmes,...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Cutting-edge technology allows students to hold virtual conversations with Holocaust survivors.

Testimony 360, the new programme from the Holocaust Educational Trust uses innovative technology to bring the people and places...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Schools

Private school body takes legal action against government on VAT

The Independent Schools Council said the decision 'has not been taken lightly' but it is 'defending the rights of...

Samantha Booth
Schools

Schools must be reimbursed for any national insurance hike, say unions

Reports suggested the government could increase national insurance contributions

Samantha Booth
Schools

6 key school findings from biggest annual parent survey

Worrying findings on school absences, home education and children feeling unsafe at school

Samantha Booth
Schools

EdCity: The community inclusion HQ with schools at its heart

Ark Schools teams up with Hammersmith and Fulham council to turn a run-down playground into a new community

John Dickens

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 Comments

  1. Robert Hardy

    Perhaps time to give schools back to local authorities and reestablish county architects departments. Our children and grandchildren will be paying billions and billions of debt run up by this failed government and it’s incompetant ‘private is always best’ mantra.