Ofsted

‘Don’t scapegoat leaders over bad Ofsteds’, says top trust boss

United Learning chief's blueprint for Ofsted reform also calls for end of ungraded inspections and 'simplified' primary visits

United Learning chief's blueprint for Ofsted reform also calls for end of ungraded inspections and 'simplified' primary visits

Sir Jon Coles
Exclusive

All trusts and governors should “guarantee” to staff that “no one will be sacked because of an Ofsted report”, the boss of the country’s biggest academy trust has said.

This would “sharply reduce the fear” of the watchdog, added Sir Jon Coles, the chief executive of the United Learning trust. “We as leaders in the trust should examine ourselves, not scapegoat an individual school leader.”

In a blueprint for Ofsted reform, shared with Schools Week, Coles also called for ungraded inspections to be ditched.

Inspections should instead be “longer or better resourced”, inspectors paid more and primary visits “simplified”, the plan said.

Labour, likely to be in government next month, has proposed big accountability reforms, including the end of single-word judgments and introducing annual safeguarding audits.

But Coles said Ofsted was “not fundamentally broken. There are things that can be improved… but also some significant strengths that we need to keep.”

‘Change governance, not heads’

While some of these are “in Ofsted’s hands, others rely on government action or changes in behaviour in the wider school system”.

No one “has been or will be sacked as a result of an Ofsted judgment” at United Learning, he said.

“I’d consider it a huge failure if Ofsted came up with something that we were not aware of in one of our schools … we’d have completely failed in our job.”

Instead, the “default setting” should be a “a change of governance rather than leadership”.

Schools Week analysis previously revealed three in five leaders had moved on a year after receiving an ‘inadequate’ judgment in 2021-22, amid a “football manager culture” of heads being fired.

But Coles said if those overseeing schools could “make sure their own evaluations are sharp enough” and their “dialogue with leaders open and honest enough”, then every governing body and trust could “guarantee” that “no one will be sacked because of an Ofsted report”.

“Every governing body, trust board and local authority can and should commit to knowing their school or schools well enough that Ofsted will not identify unexpected problems during an inspection – and that they will never therefore remove a leader on the basis of an inspection.

“That would sharply reduce the fear of Ofsted and greatly improve the quality of governance in the system.”

‘Ofsted isn’t broken, it needs more cash’ 

While Labour has set out the broad direction of Ofsted reform, it has promised to consult on how to achieve it.

Coles said the “current narrative about inspection has a disproportionate sense that ‘Ofsted is broken’. In our experience this isn’t true.”

The trust, which now has 90 schools, has had about 150 inspections over the past decade, including 23 since September.

The current framework was “the best we have had in recent years” and required tweaks not an overhaul, he said.

Proposed changes put forward by Coles include ditching ungraded inspections for ‘good’ and ‘outstanding’ schools. 

Inexperienced and under-resourced inspectors often gathered “insufficient evidence to provide meaningful insight”, he said.

Ofsted’s budget was 29 per cent lower in real terms compared with 2010. A 50 per cent increase to the watchdog’s £30 million budget would have “minimal impact on the resources available to schools”.

But it would allow “longer or better resourced inspections”. Inspectors could be paid more to “attract people with the right level of seniority”.

However Frank Norris, a former Ofsted inspector and trust boss, said less inspection was needed, “but with highly skilled and respected colleagues. I am not convinced at all that piling more inspectors into a team is going to be the answer.”

‘Narrative Ofsted reports’ warning

While it may be possible to make reports “clear without a single overall judgment”, there must still be a “clear way of identifying which schools require urgent change”, the blueprint said. 

“Headline categories are meaningful and do communicate useful information,” it added.

And the current Independent Schools Inspectorate system, which is “purely narrative” with no overall grades, “should be avoided”.

“Parents should have access to the judgments made by inspectors without needing to ‘de-code’ a report.”

But Loic Menzies, visiting fellow at Sheffield Institute of Education, said if “simplicity ends up leading to misleading information, then it doesn’t really serve anyone’s interests”.

Transparency needed over complaints

Labour has also pledged annual checks on safeguarding.

But Coles said trusts and other governance authorities could instead carry out annual checks, with this validated during inspections. 

Meanwhile, trust inspections – another Labour pledge – should be “assessed by reference to the quality and improvement of the schools” in the trust.

Clarity was also needed about who reports were aimed at.

The blueprint also said complaints should be “meaningfully improved” so there was “effective redress and transparency” – rather than “closing ranks”.

Latest education roles from

INCLUSION PRACTITIONER

INCLUSION PRACTITIONER

Milton Keynes College

HOSPITALITY LECTURER

HOSPITALITY LECTURER

Milton Keynes College

Vocational Skills Coach and Technician: Science

Vocational Skills Coach and Technician: Science

Milton Keynes College

DIGITAL SKILLS TUTOR

DIGITAL SKILLS TUTOR

Milton Keynes College

EDUCATION and EXAM ADMINISTRATOR

EDUCATION and EXAM ADMINISTRATOR

Milton Keynes College

Caretaker

Caretaker

Milton Keynes College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: Discover Leader Apprenticeships with NPQs

Recent cuts to NPQ funding, as reported by Schools Week, mean 14,000 schools previously eligible for scholarships now face...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How do you tackle the MIS dilemma?

With good planning, attention to detail, and clear communication, switching MIS can be a smooth and straightforward process, but...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How can we prepare learners for their future in an ever-changing world?

By focusing their curriculums on transferable skills, digital skills, and sustainability, schools and colleges can be confident that learners...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Inspiring Education Leaders for 10 Years

The 10th Inspiring Leadership Conference is to be held on 13 and 14 June 2024 at the ICC in...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Ofsted

Ofsted wins High Court battle with school over ‘inadequate’ report

Judge says the court is 'not a proper forum for policy disagreements'

Lucas Cumiskey
Ofsted

How will ungraded Ofsted inspections work from September?

Watchdog sets out its plans after Sir Martyn Oliver scrapped subject deep dives for shorter visits

Lucas Cumiskey
Ofsted

Eight things we learned from Ofsted’s annual accounts

Inspectorate has had a 'difficult' year and faces 'significant' financial challenges, documents warn

Freddie Whittaker
Ofsted

Councils ‘hamstrung’ from supporting school leaders, review claims

But Ruth Perry's sister criticises council review for 'failing to ask key questions'

Lucas Cumiskey

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment

  1. Michael Baybutt

    Perhaps it would help if schools were relieved of the need to be social workers, mental health counsellors and family support workers. They could then focus on – oh, what was it now ? – Oh, yes! Education!