Grammar Schools

Tory leadership: A chance to tackle selection once and for all

As the candidates gear up for a televised debate, Mike Ion suggests Rishi Sunak should come out fighting for evidence-led policy and against academic selection

As the candidates gear up for a televised debate, Mike Ion suggests Rishi Sunak should come out fighting for evidence-led policy and against academic selection

25 Jul 2022, 18:01

One of the few education policy pledges to have emerged from the Tory leadership contest is Liz Truss’s commitment to end the ban on grammar schools. Like many past and current Tory cabinet ministers, Truss views grammar schools as escape routes from poverty. But the idea that selection provides bright working-class children opportunities they are denied in a comprehensive system relies heavily on highlighting past individual successes without establishing how representative they actually are – or ever were.

David Jesson’s 2007 research clearly demonstrated that the surviving grammar schools in England were and are, in the main, schools for the middle classes. What Jesson showed was that the proportion of children eligible for free school meals – which may be an imperfect measure, but is the most commonly used indicator of social disadvantage – is much lower in selective than in non-selective schools in every one of the 36 local authorities that retain at least some grammar schools.

In 1970, 47 per cent of pupils left secondary school with no qualifications. By 2019, that figure was down to 4 per cent. In 1971-72, 14 per cent of under-21s entered higher education. In 2019, it was 48 per cent. And between 1989 and 2019, the percentage of 16- to 18-year-olds in full-time education rose from 37.6 to 90.3.

Having close to half of all school leavers entering higher education is an aim that would have seemed impossibly ambitious a generation ago. And given that expenditure on education didn’t increase in real terms between the mid-1970s and the late-1990s, this remarkable increase in productivity (as measured by qualifications) is attributable in large part to the removal of the barrier of the 11-plus for some four-fifths of the population.

Only ten years ago the Tory leadership appeared to agree grammar schools were a thing of the past

Since comprehensive education was introduced, barriers to achievement for many young people have been removed. The annual government statistics of school attainment, examination results and participation in further and higher education offer clear evidence of “levelling up” over four decades. Sadly, some areas of England (such as Kent, Trafford and Buckinghamshire) have not benefitted from this impact of comprehensive schooling. But they are not proof of some ‘failed experiment’. Rather, they are evidence of what happens when the experiment is not yet tried.

But in making the case against grammar schools, it is important to emphasise that it is selection that needs reform; anti-selection campaigners are not suggesting that particular schools should be closed. There is no reason why the nation’s remaining 164 grammar schools should not remain pretty much as they are now: the same buildings and resources, the same governors, headteachers and staff, the same ethos, curriculum and uniform. Even largely the same funding.

The only real change will be in the academic profile of the pupils in attendance. Indeed, one would expect that if the quality of education really is as high as grammar school supporters suggest, progress, attainment and standards would remain largely the same too, irrespective of a more balanced pupil intake.

It was only ten years ago that the Tory leadership appeared to be of the view that grammar schools were a thing of the past. Cross-party consensus was emerging that selective schools fail to offer good value for money and do not help raise standards overall.

In a retrograde step for the party, Liz Truss has nailed her colours to the selective mast. But that doesn’t have to be a bad thing. The Tory leadership contest now has the potential to develop into a debate that addresses, once and for all, the archaic and socially exclusive policy of academic selection.

The question is: In the race to pursue the levelling up agenda that won Johnson the last general election, does Rishi Sunak have the stomach to stand up for the evidence?

Latest education roles from

IT Technician

IT Technician

Harris Academy Morden

Teacher of Geography

Teacher of Geography

Harris Academy Orpington

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Exams Assistant

Exams Assistant

Richmond and Hillcroft Adult & Community College

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Solihull College and University Centre

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

It’s Education’s Time to Shine: Celebrate your Education Community in 2025!

The deadline is approaching to nominate a colleague, team, whole school or college for the 2025 Pearson National Teaching...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: An Apprenticeship Success Story

Last year’s NPQ funding cuts meant that half of England’s teachers faced costs of up to £4,000 to complete...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Embedding Formative Assessment: not just a box-ticking exercise but something long-term and meaningful for all

Our EFA programme has been proven to help schools achieve better GCSE results, as evidenced by the EEF. Find...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Building capacity in family support to tackle low school attendance 

Persistent and severe school absence impacts children, families, and communities—especially in disadvantaged areas. School-Home Support’s Attendance Support and Development Programme...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Grammar Schools

Warning over grammar’s plan to open ‘affiliate’ schools overseas

The plan skirts close to what is permissible in academy funding rules, finance experts have warned 

Lucas Cumiskey
Grammar Schools

Mock 11-plus entrance exams boost grammars’ funds

Investigation finds tens of thousands raised through PTA-run tests help grammars pay for laptops, cricket nets and new buildings

Jack Dyson
Grammar Schools

Grammar school head guilty of misconduct over illegal exclusions

But no ban for ex-head of school that booted out year 12 students over AS-level results, after case referred...

Amy Walker
Grammar Schools

Ministers intervene to delay grammar schools expansion plan

Council says changes will pave way to admit more pupils into its selective schools

Jack Dyson

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *