Academies

Schools bill: Ministers want veto on academy trustees

New DfE documents reveal more about powers sought by ministers in schools bill

New DfE documents reveal more about powers sought by ministers in schools bill

27 May 2022, 9:00

More from this author

Academy trusts will have to seek government approval for trustee and member appointments, new documents on the schools bill reveal.

The government will also hand itself the power to chop and change new national standards for academies and rules on intervening in trusts – without passing new primary legislation.

The Department for Education published fresh details on how it will overhaul academy rules this week.

Trusts will need governance arrangements that “state no board members or trustees are appointed before the secretary of state has had an opportunity to assess their suitability”.

Sam Henson, policy director at the National Governance Association, said it “feels like a power grab”.

For appointments of chairs, trusts currently send proof to regulators of enhanced DBS checks, identity verification and extra checks on individuals who have lived abroad. Officials also confirm they are not banned from teaching or management.

But chairs themselves currently handle checks on other trustees, members and local governors.

NGA’s “assumption and hope” is the proposed reforms only expand current rules for chairs and members to all trustees.

‘Unnecessary bureaucracy at best’

But Henson added: “Extending this seems like unnecessary bureaucracy at best… If it’s anything more, we could potentially have a real issue.”

Governors already report delays when DfE countersigns chair appointments, prompting fears it could exacerbate recruitment challenges.

academy schools bill
Henson

“We’re not sure how the department has the capacity to do it for all,” Henson said.

The changes are among several in the schools bill sparking fears of ministerial overreach.

The draft schools bill, currently making its way through the House of Lords, is primary legislation.

But it will create “delegated powers” for the education secretary to make further changes through secondary legislation, which is easier to get through parliament.

These will include new changes to the academy standards, replacing funding agreements which currently differ depending on when they were signed.

Schools bill sets academy collaboration duty

However, the government said the new standards mostly consolidate existing duties in one place. But there are some new duties.

Trusts face a new duty to work “constructively with each other, local authorities and the wider public and third sectors”. They will have to “behave with civic responsibility, working broadly to benefit children in their communities”.

Meanwhile, a “minor change” to complaints-handling processes allows government to “assess the reasonableness of complaint decisions made by academy trusts”. They can already do this for local authority schools.

Standards will also cover areas including curriculum, welfare, cultural development, school day and term length, assessment, whistleblowing, premises, leadership, admissions and spending.

The DfE has said that any update to standards will be subject to a debate and affirmatory vote in both houses of parliament every time they are updated.

It pledged to consult with sector representatives on the first set of standards and “any subsequent changes”.



More from this theme

Academies

Council to lend academy £1m for Holland Park bid as Harris also enters battle

A standalone academy co-sponsored by Kensington and Chelsea is vying with Harris and United Learning to run the scandal-hit...

Tom Belger

Academies, Politics

Zahawi guts his own schools bill in humiliating climbdown

The controversial new powers - including academy standards - will be revisited once a regulation review has concluded

Freddie Whittaker
Academies

DfE launches regulatory review to ‘future proof’ academy trusts

Amanda Spielman, Leora Cruddas and trust representatives will advise Baroness Barran on accountability reforms

Freddie Whittaker
Academies

How turnaround trust plans to fix ‘orphan’ school problem

The St Joseph CMAT's chief executive compared its task to a 'mission to Mars', but the pilot could spark...

Tom Belger
Academies

United Learning’s chief operating officer leaves for private school association

Dominic Norrish was 'integral' to trust's success, United say

Schools Week Reporter
Academies, Politics

Zahawi changes tack on ‘kryptonite’ schools bill reforms

Government prepares shake-up of school reforms amid mounting pressure from Conservative rebels

Freddie Whittaker

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.