Schools

BESA threatens legal action over ‘unlawful’ DfE plans for Oak

The British Education Suppliers Association claims government breached rules on subsidies, procurement and consultation

The British Education Suppliers Association claims government breached rules on subsidies, procurement and consultation

16 May 2022, 10:39

More from this author

Oak academy

The British Educational Suppliers Association has taken the first formal step towards legal action over the Department for Education’s plan to move Oak National Academy into public hands.

Trade association BESA claims it was “unfairly and unlawfully excluded” from consultation over the move, subsidies for the online school are “unlawful” and the DfE failed to properly consider the decision’s impact on the educational services market.

Education secretary Nadhim Zahawi had confirmed in March Oak would become part of the DfE as an arm’s length national curriculum body this autumn.

He called it “one of our greatest achievements”, with its free online learning materials hugely popular with schools during the pandemic.

But Caroline Wright, director general of BESA, said it had “no other option” but to take legal action. The organisation gave the DfE notice today of its proposed judicial review claim.

She warned the move would “unfairly replicate” hundreds of UK businesses’ own curriculum resources, threatening hundreds of millions of pounds of investment and hundreds of jobs.

“The government appears to want to transform Oak into a national curriculum body that would work closely with Ofsted to deliver government-approved content for schools,” the letter said.

Such a move also threatens to “curtail” teacher and school autonomy to use the resources they wish, she added.

BESA said it wants a resolution without court intervention, but has called for the department to put its plans for Oak on hold. The body also wants a consultation to be run on the plans.

BESA’s letter to the DfE argues there is “no evidence” it is creating the arm’s length body as a last resort, as required by Cabinet Office guidance. Government is also accused of refusing requests to release its business case – which must be drawn up for ALBs to show multiple tests have been met to justify their creation.

Meanwhile the DfE is accused of failing to properly assess the impact of its proposals. BESA said its own review found 63 per cent of schools surveyed were against the DfE creating and providing free curriculum content post-pandemic.

BESA also claimed that “schools do not value free curriculum content”, highlighting its findings that just a quarter of primary schools and a tenth of secondaries believe free content compares well with paid-for content.

The DfE’s own decision “appears to have been taken without conducting research on anything like the scale of BESA’s surveys”, and there is reportedly “no evidence” the DfE considered BESA research, the letter adds.

Proposals have also proceeded without “meaningful consultation” as required, BESA claims. It highlights rules too which state procurement must not be designed “with the intention of unduly favouring or disadvantaging certain economic operators”.

BESA makes further arguments about alleged breaches of UK and EU subsidy rules, suggesting there is no evidence of a “market failure” or “equity rationale” to justify public funding for Oak.

A DfE spokesperson said: “The decision to create an arm’s length body that will support teachers to deliver excellent lessons and build on the success of Oak National Academy has been taken following careful consideration, and we are confident that due process has been followed.

“We have met with BESA and other trade organisations on a number of occasions over recent months to share our thinking and the department will continue to engage with stakeholders on this policy. Market engagement is an important part of this process and we welcome views from the sector on our proposals.”

Latest education roles from

Chief Education Officer (Deputy CEO)

Chief Education Officer (Deputy CEO)

Romero Catholic Academy Trust

Director of Academy Finance and Operations

Director of Academy Finance and Operations

Ormiston Academies Trust

Principal & Chief Executive

Principal & Chief Executive

Truro & Penwith College

Group Director of Marketing, Communications & External Engagement

Group Director of Marketing, Communications & External Engagement

London & South East Education Group

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

AI Safety: From DfE Guidance to Classroom Confidence

Darren Coxon, edtech consultant and AI education specialist, working with The National College, explores the DfE’s expectations for AI...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How accurate spend information is helping schools identify savings

One the biggest issues schools face when it comes to saving money on everyday purchases is a lack of...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Building Character, Increasing Engagement and Growing Leaders: A Whole School Approach

Research increasingly shows that character education is just as important as academic achievement in shaping pupils’ long-term success. Studies...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Educators launch national AI framework to guide schools and colleges

More than 250 schools and colleges across the UK have already enrolled in AiEd Certified, a new certification framework...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Politics, Schools

Reform government would ‘root out teachers brainwashing kids’ says MP Lee Anderson

Reform UK members tell party conference of need to crack down on 'brainwashing' teachers and stop schools 'becoming indoctrination...

Lydia Chantler-Hicks
Schools

Farage: ‘Let’s start teaching trades and services at school’

Reform leader also says he ‘will not stand for kids’ minds being poisoned in schools with a twisted interpretation...

Lydia Chantler-Hicks
Schools

Staff want compensation after summer cyber-attack

Schools warned incident could increase risk of phishing, fraud and identity theft for impacted employees

John Dickens
Schools

Lockdown: The schools forced to take emergency measures

Union calls for 'comprehensive' guidance as leaders warn of communications difficulties during incidents

Jack Dyson

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *