Alternative provision

Alternative provision: Let disrupted pupils repeat year 11, says de Souza

DfE should also fund 'graduated stepdown programme of support for all year 11 leavers'

DfE should also fund 'graduated stepdown programme of support for all year 11 leavers'


The government should fund pupils who arrive in alternative provision (AP) late or face disruption to their GCSEs to repeat year 11, the children’s commissioner has said.

Dame Rachel de Souza also said funding should be provided to offer a “graduated stepdown programme of support for all year 11 leavers”, amid concerns AP schools lack the resources to support the transition into post-16 education.

Polling of young people by Opinium for de Souza’s office found children attending AP were far less likely to say they were confident they would get the education they wanted (53 per cent) than all children (74 per cent).

There was a similar gap when asked whether they would learn the skills needed for a good job (52 per cent vs 72 per cent) and whether they thought they would have a job they were happy with (50 per cent vs 67 per cent).

AP leaders said they “needed to support AP leavers for a period after they left school, to ensure that they sustained a positive destination”, but this support was “difficult to provide”.

Settings “are only funded for the children on roll, and often do not have the capacity to provide additional support to previous Year 11s”, the report warned.

In response, the government should fund alternative providers to “offer a graduated stepdown programme of support for all year 11 leavers and, where necessary, provide an opportunity to resit the final year of AP for some learners who have had a disrupted key stage 4”.

As part of its AP funding review, DfE should look at how it can provide “ring-fenced funding for the work AP schools do to support their children to transition to positive post-16 destinations”.

Pay for careers, work experience and ‘extended support programme’

The review “should look at how to create a limited number of post-16 placements for children who have had a disrupted key stage 4, who have entered AP very late in year 11 or who have been unable to access education during their exam years.”

These placements “should enable children to resit their final year in alternative provision and to study the qualifications they need for post-16 pathways”.

The review should also look at how to finance careers advisors, work experience, and an “extended support programme for all children transitioning from AP to a post-16 destination”.

Ministers should also review accountability measures, to “ensure they capture the extent to which AP leavers secure and sustain positive post-16 destinations”.

de Souza said her research showed children in AP were “deeply ambitious and see getting a good job or career as a priority”.

“However, often they are not given the support they need to succeed… These children are every bit as ambitious as other children. It is up to us as adults to match that ambition.”

A damning Ofsted and Care Quality Commission report in February found AP was in “desperate need of reform” amid “systemic issues” that lead to “inconsistent outcomes”.

de Souza’s report also called on the DfE to develop an AP workforce strategy and train AP teachers to become PSHE specialists. The AP taskforce programme, which provides wraparound support for children in AP in 21 areas, should be rolled out nationally.

More from this theme

Alternative provision

Unregistered AP clampdown: Everything you need to know

Time limits on placements, new national standards and a council-run quality-assurance process proposed by the DfE

Freddie Whittaker
Alternative provision

DfE plans ‘national standards’ for unregistered AP

Ministers say unregistered provision should be 'an intervention, not a destination'

Freddie Whittaker
Alternative provision

Revealed: The 20 new AP free schools approved by ministers

Leading academy trust secures four alternative provision free schools while others are snubbed

Samantha Booth
Alternative provision

AP in ‘desperate need of reform’, damning Ofsted and CQC report says

'Too many children have negative experiences in AP', report says, with lack of oversight leading to 'ineffective practice'

Lucas Cumiskey
Alternative provision

‘Out of sight, out of mind’: The rise of unregistered alternative provision

Thousands of children are being educated in unregistered alternative provision where teachers require neither qualifications nor criminal record checks....

Jessica Hill
Alternative provision

Trusts queue to open alternative provision free schools

The schools form part of the Department for Education’s SEND and AP improvement plan

Samantha Booth

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Keith

    Except this is a problem well before they get to Year 11.
    Year 6 SAT are still the “best” predictors for how students perform in Year 11.
    That suggests the issue stem from primary.

    • Anointing

      I’m 16 and I just come to the UK can someone help me know how I can request a secondary school to take me in so I can do my Gcse in year 11 please I need help