Academies

Ministers will miss 2030 MAT target, report warns

An NFER report warns white paper vision would need conversions at 'unprecedented' speed, threatening standards

An NFER report warns white paper vision would need conversions at 'unprecedented' speed, threatening standards

26 Jan 2023, 0:00

More from this author

The government will “certainly” miss its 2030 target for all schools joining larger multi-academy trusts, as it would require “unprecedented” upheaval that threatens standards, a new report says.

Here are the key findings from a National Foundation for Educational Research study, published today, on “transitioning to a multi-academy trust-led system”.

1. ‘Unprecedented’ academy conversions required 

Schools would have to join MATs and trusts merge “at an unprecedented scale” to have all schools in MATs of 10 schools or 7,500 pupils by 2030 – the 2021 ‘opportunity for all’ white paper’s vision.

The study found 25 maintained mainstream schools and three single-academy trusts would need to convert every week. Schools Week analysis shows actual conversions only averaged 7.5 per week in December.

Currently, more than half of academies are in trusts with fewer than 10 schools – which rises to more than two-thirds in London and the north-west.

Julie McCulloch

Julie McCulloch, policy director at school leaders’ union ASCL, dubbed the 2030 target “totally unrealistic”.

NFER research director Jenna Julius said the Department for Education should instead “prioritise a slower transition that allows time to build MAT capacity”. 

2. Schools and councils frosty on academisation …

But do those schools even want to join MATs?

Just six per cent of the 33 councils who completed the NFER survey were in favour of all schools being in strong MATs of 10 schools or 7,500 pupils by 2030.

More than half of LAs said their local maintained and standalone academy schools alike were opposed to joining multi-academy trusts.

Only around one in 10 councils felt retaining schools was no longer financially viable, or wanted powers to force conversions – as proposed by DfE under the since-ditched schools bill.

The report notes 2010 academy legislation and the 2016 white paper both sparked mass conversions.

But it warned a repeat is “unlikely”, explaining: “Given the current political context, the slowdown in academisation in recent years and the scale of academisation and trust growth that would be required, it is likely to take a significant period for the government to achieve an all-MAT system, certainly beyond 2030,” the report said.

3. … and councils lack cash to form MATs

Two-thirds of councils surveyed showed interest in DfE proposals for LA-established trusts.

The NFER called it an “important avenue” to boost conversions, but said more cash was needed.

The study found just two in five councils expected to launch MATs within three years; only one in five applied to a DfE pilot.

The NFER put the gap down to “concerns … about their ability to fund the process”, with two-thirds of councils saying they lacked both resources and clarity needed. The DfE was approached for an update on its LA MAT pilot.

A Local Government Association spokesperson said the government should widen its plans beyond areas without “strong” trusts, noting it would help reluctant converters remain connected to LAs.

Four-fifths of council respondents feared even some schools looking to convert would be “left behind”, unwanted by MATs. Meanwhile trust funding pots for growth are also “not commensurate with a rapid academisation target”.

4. Rapid growth threatens standards

The NFER also warns rapid growth “risks creating issues for trust quality, as it did during the initial rapid expansion of MATs”, with schools joining “inappropriate” trusts.

Ministers had to “pause” the growth of large trusts, including E-ACT and the Academies Enterprise Trust, around a decade ago over concerns they had grown too quickly and standards had fallen.

Plymouth CAST’s birth from 34 simultaneous conversions in 2014 has also been described as “cautionary tale”, with stinging criticism from Ofsted.

The NFER report states: “Some schools might rush to join a MAT, which is not necessarily an appropriate match, for fear of being forced to join another MAT in the future.”

This risks creating “substantial medium-term challenges” – particularly given the lack of an “appropriate” regulatory framework – and could impact other priorities like Covid-19 recovery.

NFER also flagged councils’ warnings that mass conversions would “inevitably divert resources from other areas”, including pressing priorities like the cost-of-living crisis and special educational needs and disability funding.

McCulloch also urged DfE to prioritise “pressing issues” like staffing shortages and funding. “These are much greater threats to educational standards over the next few years than some schools not being in MATs.”

5. ‘Lack of evidence’ for trust vision

The NFER urged government to prioritise a delayed academy regulation review, with a “clear need” for a national regulatory framework for trust performance – and “high-quality evidence” needed to underpin it.

It is “not clear” whether proposals will “adequately assess trust quality”, with reliance on performance measures “potentially…misleading”. Evidence is currently lacking on the optimal trust size, the report noted, and research has shown “academisation alone does not necessarily improve school outcomes”.

Nearly one in 10 MATs have a majority of schools rated less than ‘good’, raising questions about whether there is “sufficient focus” on improving MAT schools.

There is also “considerable variation” in how quickly DfE regional directors transfer failing academies into new trusts, with re-brokerage typically 18 months faster in the east of England than the north-east.

The DfE was approached for comment.

Latest education roles from

Principal (Harrow College) – HRUC

Principal (Harrow College) – HRUC

FEA

Deputy Director of Apprenticeships

Deputy Director of Apprenticeships

Manchester Metropolitan University

Independent Non- Executive Director (INED)

Independent Non- Executive Director (INED)

League Football Education

Initial Teacher Training Programme Lead

Initial Teacher Training Programme Lead

Scarborough Sixth Form College

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

Retire Early, Live Fully: What Teachers Need to Consider First

Specialist Financial Adviser, William Adams, from Wesleyan Financial Services discusses what teachers should be considering when it comes to...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

AI Safety: From DfE Guidance to Classroom Confidence

Darren Coxon, edtech consultant and AI education specialist, working with The National College, explores the DfE’s expectations for AI...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

How accurate spend information is helping schools identify savings

One the biggest issues schools face when it comes to saving money on everyday purchases is a lack of...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Building Character, Increasing Engagement and Growing Leaders: A Whole School Approach

Research increasingly shows that character education is just as important as academic achievement in shaping pupils’ long-term success. Studies...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

Academies

More standalone schools on the brink as deficits grow

Seventy-five trusts – one with a deficit of almost £6 million – raised concerns about their ability to continue...

Jack Dyson
Academies

Specialist MAT given notice to improve after seeking bailout

12-school trust said it had to ask for 'emergency' government cash after 'significant delays' to SEND and free school...

Jack Dyson
Academies

Officials kept mum about academy probe as merger decided

Revelation reopens debate around the transparency of important academy decisions

Jack Dyson
Academies

CEO gender pay gap halves after closing three years in a row

But men still paid £5k more than women, CST study finds

Jack Dyson

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *