Review by Tony Brown

21 Mar 2016, 6:00

Tony Brown – The beginnings of school-led teacher training: New challenges for university teacher education

Tony Brown, Professor of mathematics education, Manchester Metropolitan University

 

What have you been working on?

I started with a couple of colleagues about five years ago who were researching a new course called the Graduate Teacher Programme where there was a very small amount of time spent in university. They were wondering what happened to the traditional university content, given the students only have nine or ten days in university.

We were trying to get a sense of what happened to theory and subject knowledge as a consequence of the university element being squeezed so much. We did that for about three years and had various articles published as a consequence.

Following that work, the university agreed to provide us with a research assistant so we could do a bit more of a wider study. For the past two and half years, we carried out more than 100 interviews to try to get a sense of how different people, differently positioned across the landscape, were experiencing the changes.

What do the findings show?

In terms of the report there has definitely been a change in how teacher education is experienced by trainees, and educators.

The big thing for me is the non-alignment with Europe; at the same time as England has gone through school-based or school-led provision, most European countries have increased training up to five years at university followed by two years in school; five years as opposed to 30 days. Does that have consequences for teachers getting jobs in other countries? There’s a European teacher network whereby you are able to get jobs in different countries if you have that sort of backing, but English teachers are not actually getting that same sort of training.

What is interesting about it?

Quite a few things, like the actual nature of the subjects taught changing because of the compression in the time at university. So, for example, if you have someone coming in from a chemistry degree they would talk in relatively sophisticated language. Traditionally the role of a PGCE would be to enable them to get that into the style of language that is more accessible to children. That side of training is much reduced now.

There’s quite a lot of other issues, but the fact the changes have been so fast has meant it’s quite difficult for long-term contracts for various people to be put in place.

There’s a sense of ongoing turbulence at university because they are never sure what their job is going to be the next year. There was one particular case where they had a relatively poor Ofsted judgment and, as a result, lost a sizeable part of their allocation and had to lay staff off.

But they were then allowed to recruit more students again, on condition they were School Direct students. So, basically, they had the same number of students two years later as they did before, but schools had a much stronger say in terms of what that student’s experience was.

What do you hope its impact will be?

There’s definitely a positive dimension to having school practice linked to teacher education provision. I don’t think theory is the main purpose of university – it is actually about enabling people to move from specialist academic areas into working with children in those areas at an appropriate level, and trying to make that development of professional capability the most important thing.

It also means some subjects such as art, drama and music are effectively squeezed out; if you are a primary generalist teacher, you might be getting two hours on art in university. On the Continent you have much more time to develop those skills.

 

Latest education roles from

Special Teaching Assistant

Special Teaching Assistant

Priory School

Science Teacher

Science Teacher

Harris Academy Orpington

Teacher of Art History

Teacher of Art History

Harris Westminster Sixth Form

Behaviour Mentor and Sports Coach

Behaviour Mentor and Sports Coach

Harris Science Academy East London

Progress & Support Tutor – The Engineering Centre

Progress & Support Tutor – The Engineering Centre

Calderdale College

Learning Support Assistant / Teaching Assistant / SEN / SEND

Learning Support Assistant / Teaching Assistant / SEN / SEND

MidKent College

More Reviews

The Conversation – with Sarah Gallagher

Training teachers for primary PE, designing classroom tasks efficiently, and parental experiences of the broken SEND system

Find out more

The Conversation – with Frances Akinde 

A new anti-racism campaign, a SEND crisis short on solutions, the challenge of change, and the Francis review's social...

Find out more

The Conversation – with Rob Gasson

A lighter look at the week's education landscape, some reflections on agency and 'enslaved teachers', and a powerful tool...

Find out more

More from this theme

Unfinished Business: The life and legacy of Sir Tim Brighouse

A veritable who's who of education pays tribute to a giant and aims to pick up where he left...

Find out more

The Conversation – with Jess Mahdavi-Gladwell

Classroom technique, pupil wellbeing, the impact of screen time, and having a bad day at the chalkface

Find out more

The Conversation – with Shekeila Scarlett

Teenagers' memory and their mental health, the truth about smartphones in schools, and an unvarnished account of joining an...

Find out more

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment