News

Lancashire is fourth undersubscribed UTC to close



Another of the government’s flagship University Technical Colleges has announced plans to close this summer after reporting a lack of financial viability.

According to the Burnley Express, UTC Lancashire in Burnley will close in August, just two years after it opened.

Government data released earlier this year showed the college had just 113 pupils on its roll, despite having a capacity of 800. Its pupil numbers had fallen from 120 since 2014/15.

But it is not the first of the 14 to 19 vocational institutions to run into difficulty.

Hackney UTC in London and Black Country UTC in Walsall both closed last August, both having reported problems recruiting pupils. And earlier this year, Central Bedfordshire UTC announced it too would cease operating this summer.

The brainchild of former education secretary Lord Baker, UTCs have often opened to much fanfare and after large capital investment by central government in their sites and buildings. According to government figures, almost £3.3 million was spent establishing Hackney UTC, while it remains to be seen how much of the £9.5 million set aside for the college in Walsall was used.

Local media are reporting that the price tag attached to Lancashire UTC is £10 million, but the government is unlikely to reveal exactly how much was spent on the project until long after it closes, as has been the case with similar closures.

Low pupil numbers has been a factor in all four closures announced or executed so far, and a review following the Black Country UTC closure has sparked a call from government for all UTCs to operate within academy trusts, rather than as standalone institutions with university, FE college and business backers.

Skills minister Nick Boles, who has also promised extra funding to support UTCs, told Parliament in March of the success of Leigh UTC, which he said was a “particularly good example”, not least because it was “part of a very successful multi-academy trust (MAT)”.

He continued: “That is a situation that we want to see replicated across the UTC movement, because UTCs are stronger inside MATs.”

But school leaders have expressed doubts about the proposal, with one labelling it “troubling”.

Russell Hobby, general secretary of the National Association of Headteachers, has warned that putting UTCs into trusts risked giving academy chains a loophole in new GCSE requirements, since they will be exempt from the requirement to have 90 per cent of pupils in a school study English Baccalaureate (EBacc) subjects until 16.

Speaking to the Burnley Express, Rob Dubrow-Marshall, a board member of the Visions Learning Trust, which runs the UTC, said the decision was “hugely disappointing”, but said closure was the “only available option” due to low pupil numbers.



Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

2 Comments

  1. Sadly this was utterly predictable. There should now be a review of the UTC, Studio School and Free School programme to esablish a more sustainable model. It’s lunacy to continue pouring multi million pounds of capital funding into establishing these institutions with poor chance of them remaining viable. It’s well known that small secondary schools and sixth forms struggle already with the funding arrangements. Quite often these UTCs are being parachuted into areas which already have surplus places 14-16 and where it makes little sense to parents to transfer their children at the age of 14 from their secondary schools. These facilities need to be part of larger schools or colleges. It’s a failed model.

    • Millions of pounds wasted on UTCs and studio schools which have failed to attract pupils and on free schools which never opened or which were set up where there was no need. Further expansion of UTCs and studio schools should be stopped and Lord Baker’s other idea, Career Colleges, should also be halted. The accounts of The Career Colleges Trust, registered at the same address as 80+ other companies, mostly linked via directors, subsidiaries etc, for y/e 31/8/14 says it wants there to be 40 of these career colleges in four years offering vocational courses for 14-19 year-olds. The only different to UTCs is that career colleges seem to be courses offered in establishments that already exist – not discrete ‘colleges’ at all.