Review by Jon Hutchinson


27 Apr 2019, 5:00


Jon Hutchinson’s top blogs of the week 15 April 2019

A part-transcript of a power and conflict poetry lesson with year 11 – “My Last Duchess”

Claire Stoneman


No matter how long you’ve been in the classroom, when an observer enters your classroom, you still get that flash of anxiety. It is, therefore, difficult to overstate the professional courage and generosity offered by Claire Stoneman, who invited more than 30 teachers from around the country to watch an English lesson at ResearchEd Birmingham. She has transcribed the whole thing in this fascinating post. One thing that stands out for me is the way that watertight routines are presented within a “purpose over power” context. For example: “Year 11 enter in silence…CS hands them the Do Now as they enter…CS waits for a minute as pupils unpack bags quickly. Scans room. Doesn’t move from spot…Pupils sit down immediately with no fuss. It is 54 seconds into the lesson.”

Do students have agency or not?

Tom Sherrington


There are few people writing about education who can synthesise and summarise the best available evidence like Tom Sherrington does. What makes his work so compelling is that the real-life classroom is always centre-ground, with common-sense applications constantly offered. More than this, though, he takes on the thorny debates in education, and does so without bombast, cutting through ideology and dogma on either side. Such is the case with this post, which tackles student agency. Whilst acknowledging the efficacy, and at times necessity, of “no-excuses” behaviour policies, Sherrington asserts that: “Silent corridors can’t be an end-goal; surely they can only be a means to an end. At some point they have to be phased out if true agency and sincere trust are to be fostered.” This measured analysis offers huge amounts in our shared goal of fostering positive use of student agency.

Testing really isn’t the problem

Simon Smith


Every year at its annual conference the National Education Union passes motions to abolish everything. And every year Twitter dives into their respective trenches and begins hurling grenades. This year was different, though, because Jeremy Corbyn promised that Labour, if elected, would abolish SATs. For primary headteacher Simon Smith, however, the tests are the wrong target. The “real issue is the accountability inherent in current set-up. Let’s not forget it was never meant to be like this. There were never supposed to be league tables and school comparisons. These are the things that create the crazy culture. Our current accountability system is fundamentally damaging to schools, staff and ultimately pupils.” There is a danger of throwing out the baby with the bathwater in addressing legitimate concerns around accountability. Testing can be a powerful learning tool, and is more valid, reliable and fair than teacher assessment. So it’s pleasing that, despite their many shortcomings, Smith opens with “I’m going to say it I don’t agree with the idea of getting rid of SATs”.

Zero tolerance

The Grumpy Teacher


Both advocates and dissenters of “zero-tolerance” get a fair hearing from the Grumpy Teacher. (S)he begins by listing the “tremendous advantages to a zero-tolerance approach…it promotes good behaviour…[is] consistent…eliminates the whole ‘he’s all right for me’ culture…and I do very much recognise that some teachers can undermine others by being too lax”. So what’s not to love? Well, for Grumpy Teacher, zero-tolerance is chemotherapy. It may well blitz chaotic behaviour, but in doing so it eradicates flexibility, basic common sense, and, most damagingly, teachers’ relationships with their pupils. A number of powerful examples show where context would override the immediate consequence for any violation of the “rules”. I’m sympathetic to the zero-tolerance line, but Grumpy even convinced me to let off the 13-year-old cricketer who shouted “Oh for fuck’s sake” in front of a teacher from another school.

More Reviews

The magic in the space between by Ian and Hilary Wigston

Just like the best mentoring, this book is less a how-to manual than a thought-provoking catalyst for change, writes...

Find out more

Gerry Robinson’s blogs of the week, 6 September 2021

Gerry Robinson’s top blogs look at welcoming students back, taking nothing for granted, leading with honesty, and spreading the...

Find out more

12 books to look forward to this summer and beyond

JL Dutaut ends the academic year with a look ahead at the books on education publishers’ slates that are...

Find out more

Blogs of the year, 2020/21

Each of our blog reviewers selects one blog that has particularly impacted them this year and explains why  ...

Find out more

The boy question by Mark Roberts

Don’t be put off by the title, writes Stephen Lockyer. This book is a goldmine of wisdom and practical...

Find out more

Melissa Jane’s blogs of the week, 5 July 2021

Melissa Jane’s top blogs look at quality CPD, constructive negativity, echo chambers, and the ongoing battle against homophobia  ...

Find out more

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *