School buildings

Councils still paying PFI bills for closed schools (but some can’t talk about it)

Investigation exposes ongoing complexities of PFI deals, use of gagging clauses and how the DfE paid off contracts in early academy days

Investigation exposes ongoing complexities of PFI deals, use of gagging clauses and how the DfE paid off contracts in early academy days

Investigation

A council in the north of England remains locked in a battle to end a £657,000-a-year private finance initiative (PFI) contract for a school that closed four years ago, highlighting the “complexities” that continue to plague such deals.

A Schools Week investigation has also uncovered documents that reveal ministers footed the bill to end such agreements during the early years of the academies programme to force moves out of local authority control.

Meanwhile, controversial gagging clauses, called non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), have been issued to several PFI school leaders, prompting transparency concerns.

‘Power in companies’ hands’

Andrew Chubb
Andrew Chubb

Andrew Chubb, of Project PFI, said schools and local authorities “through no fault of their own” found themselves ill-equipped to understand the complexities of the contracts, “which leaves the balance of power in any negotiations in the hands of the private sector”.

“Failure to grip these contracts and manage them appropriately means it’s almost inevitable the quality of service will be substandard, and costs will be far higher than they should be, to the detriment of school budgets.”

Successive governments have used PFI to fund the construction or refurbishment of schools since the late 1990s.

Private companies carry out the work and maintain sites in exchange for mortgage-style payments, normally over 25-year contracts – which often rise beyond inflation – before handing them over to taxpayers.

Council’s years-long negotiations

Kirklees Council revealed through freedom of information that it is still “working to remove Almondbury High” from its PFI contract – four years after the school shut.

The site was used for 12 months to accommodate pupils from a neighbouring school that was undergoing extensions.

In October 2021, councillors greenlit plans for officers to begin talks to bring the agreement to a halt to pave the way for a £21 million special school to be built on the site.

Documents prepared ahead of the vote noted that a “deed of variation to the project agreement” would have to be secured to stop the authority from having to continue paying its £657,000 annual unitary charge.

They noted “the monetary impact” of the contract – which runs until September 2033 – with Kirklees Schools Services Limited.

The council said it had “continued to pay a charge under the agreed terms of the contract”.

But fees “have been reduced during this period and there were buildings needing maintenance in order to protect the on-site swimming pool and keep it in use for both the local community and the school swimming programme”.

“We are now in the pre-planning stage of our ambitious plans to rebuild and relocate one of our existing special schools, Woodley School and College, by using the Almondbury site to create superb new facilities.”

Meanwhile, Wirral Council was saddled with PFI payments following Kingsway Academy’s closure in 2018.

Council documents, published in 2021, stated the annual costs then stood at £867,500, which would rise with inflation.

But the authority said this week it paid the fees to Wirral School Services Ltd “on a reduced basis due to the site either being fully mothballed or only partially occupied”.

Historic contract terminations

Papers uncovered through FOI show the government stepped in 18 years ago to aid the academisation of two underperforming schools by terminating their PFI contracts.

Compensation was paid by the Department for Education “for the loss of potential income” this would have caused the PFI company, NewSchools (Merton), and its sub-contractors.

A Merton Council spokesperson explained this was done because “back in 2006, academy providers did not want to take on” PFI schools, so the DfE “agreed to meet the cost of changing the contract”.

Asked how much it forked out, the department said it did not hold information going back that far as it wiped financial records “seven years after the date [they were] last modified”.

In 2009, Cornwall Council secured the termination of a PFI deal for 34 schools that ensured “various disputes between the parties had settled”.

The authority would not say how much was paid to end the contract or whether any NDAs were issued.

Four years later, four schools in Stoke-on-Trent, which has more PFI primaries and secondaries than anywhere in the country, struck a deal to terminate their agreements with Transform Schools (Stoke) Ltd.

Two “negotiated an arrangement with the council and DfE which permitted them to leave…subject to them demonstrating acceptable alternative arrangements” to government officials and serving notice on the authority.

The others were relocated under the Building Schools for the Future programme. A council spokesperson said “no compensation was paid for potential loss of income from these schools”.

Widespread use of NDAs

Answers to our FOI requests also reveal big variations between local authorities in the use of NDAs.

Most said PFI contracts did not feature gagging clauses, while others rejected our FOI request as it would either take too long to track down the information or for commercial reasons.

Norfolk said “all parties” to its only PFI contract “have to abide by” NDAs. This included the local authority, the PFI company, individual schools and now multi-academy trusts.

The council “does not hold information about the specific number of people this covers” but stressed “the confidentiality clauses were part of the standard PFI contract developed at the time” by the DfE.

A spokesperson added the NDAs were used “to ensure schools consult with us”.

“[They] can decide whether they wish to discuss their experiences or their overview of operational experience within a PFI contract, but they are not allowed to disclose certain project agreements to third parties.

“If a school were to breach their NDA, the school and Norfolk County Council would be in breach of contract which could lead to financial penalties.”

Sponsoring MATs gagged

Two other authorities said the orders also covered external lawyers and PFI experts in receipt of “commercially sensitive” information.

Meanwhile, Worcestershire County Council confirmed NDAs had been distributed to two MATs since 2020.

The agreements are issued to sponsoring trusts and members of the schools’ governing bodies after the DfE has granted an academy order. Once signed, confidential documents are released.

Legal expert Jordan Glackin, of Shakespeare Martineau, said one of the reasons NDAs are used in the schools sector “is because of the sensitivity of information being shared and other confidentiality obligations subject to that”.

“It could be part of the due diligence process when an academy trust’s taking on another school.

“[In these cases] sometimes NDAs will be put in place because, if the transaction doesn’t go ahead, you’ve given information to a third party/competitor and will want to ensure that information you have provided is protected and its use is restricted.”

But Chubb noted that, when it comes to PFI, the clauses can make “it far harder for schools and councils to ensure best value is obtained from the contract”.

This is because “depending on the wording of the NDA, it may make it impossible for…[them] to obtain the independent advice they need to get best value in terms of costs and service levels”.

Semperian Asset Management Ltd, which Wirral School Services and Kirklees Schools Services are a part of, and Vercity Management Services Ltd, the company listed as Transform Schools (Stoke) Limited’s secretary on Companies House, have been approached for comment.

Latest education roles from

IT Technician

IT Technician

Harris Academy Morden

Teacher of Geography

Teacher of Geography

Harris Academy Orpington

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

Lecturer/Assessor in Electrical

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

Director of Management Information Systems (MIS)

South Gloucestershire and Stroud College

Exams Assistant

Exams Assistant

Richmond and Hillcroft Adult & Community College

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Lecturer Electrical Installation

Solihull College and University Centre

Sponsored posts

Sponsored post

It’s Education’s Time to Shine: Celebrate your Education Community in 2025!

The deadline is approaching to nominate a colleague, team, whole school or college for the 2025 Pearson National Teaching...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Navigating NPQ Funding Cuts: An Apprenticeship Success Story

Last year’s NPQ funding cuts meant that half of England’s teachers faced costs of up to £4,000 to complete...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Embedding Formative Assessment: not just a box-ticking exercise but something long-term and meaningful for all

Our EFA programme has been proven to help schools achieve better GCSE results, as evidenced by the EEF. Find...

SWAdvertorial
Sponsored post

Building capacity in family support to tackle low school attendance 

Persistent and severe school absence impacts children, families, and communities—especially in disadvantaged areas. School-Home Support’s Attendance Support and Development Programme...

SWAdvertorial

More from this theme

School buildings

£13.8bn school building maintenance backlog revealed

Unions say the government must 'go further and faster' in making school buildings fit for purpose

Lydia Chantler-Hicks
School buildings

Revealed: Asbestos row behind school’s £500k legal stand-off

Reading council issued High Court proceedings in September to recover debt and interest from Highdown School and Sixth Form...

Lucas Cumiskey
School buildings

Council barred from using £200k grant to repair schools

Barnet council wanted to move the cash from its dedicated schools grant reserves for 'urgent and unbudgeted repairs'

Jack Dyson
School buildings

Competition watchdog opens ‘suspected bid-rigging’ probe into school repair contracts

CMA says it has 'reason to suspect' companies 'illegally colluded to rig bids to secure contracts'

Freddie Whittaker

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One comment

  1. Peter Lambert

    How do Norfolk intend to enforce or ensure compliance with any NDA’s if they do not know what they are and who has them and how hard is it to add them up and give a figure. If they do have them they are obfuscating and if the don’t they fail in their due diligence and that is maladministration. So, do you report them to the ICO or Local Government Ombudsman.