Catholics slam ‘broken promise’ as faith admissions cap retained

Plans to lift the 50-per-cent admissions cap on new faith schools have been abandoned, almost two years after they were first proposed.

The Catholic Church lamented the move as a “broken promise”, but it has been hailed as a victory by secular campaigners. Ministers will instead make it easier for faith groups to open new voluntary-aided faith schools, on the proviso that they cough up 10 per cent of the capital costs themselves.

It means that two of the main tenets of the government’s 2016 ‘Schools that work for everyone’ green paper – lifting the ban on new grammar schools and scrapping the faith cap – have fallen by the wayside.

Today the government has broken its promise and dropped the pledge they made to our country’s six million Catholics

The Department for Education has today set out a series of measures aimed at increasing the number of school places in England. The next round of free school applications will finally open after a long delay, and the wheels will be set in motion on a plan to encourage existing selective schools to expand, as long as they become more inclusive.

These are part government’s long-awaited response to a consultation on the green paper, which was delayed by Theresa May’s decision to call a general election last year, and then kicked into the long grass following the Tories’ poorer-than-expected performance at the polls.

However, the government’s response document, which is expected to finally reveal the extent of the disquiet around May’s flagship grammar school expansion plans, was not available by the time Schools Week went to press.

Under the government’s revised plans to support new faith schools, the 50-per-cent cap on faith-based admissions to oversubscribed free schools will not be removed, despite rumours earlier this year that the Catholic school-educated education secretary Damian Hinds was minded to get rid of it.

<a href=httpsschoolsweekcoukdamian hinds is carefully considering lifting the faith based admissions cap target= blank rel=noopener>Damian Hinds said in January he was carefully considering whether to scrap the cap<a>

Instead, faith groups will be given extra support, and 90 per cent of the capital funding needed, to open new voluntary-aided schools.

The move is a particular blow for the Catholic Church, which was particularly restricted by the cap because Canon Law prevents its schools from turning away Catholic pupils.

“In their general election manifesto, the Conservative Party made a commitment to the Catholic community that the unfair rule effectively stopping the opening of new Catholic free schools would be lifted,” said the reverend Malcolm McMahon, the archbishop of Liverpool.

“Today the government has broken this promise, dropped the pledge they made to our country’s six million Catholics and ignored the tens of thousands of Catholics who campaigned on this issue.”

Bishop of Liverpool Malcolm McMahon

Andrew Copson, on the other hand, who leads Humanists UK and campaigns against faith schools, said the decision was a “victory for integration, mutual understanding, and the interests of children”.

Would-be sponsors will meanwhile be able to apply to open new free schools for the first time in almost two years. Wave 13 of the application process will target areas which need places or have low school standards. Hinds said this would give parents “greater choice in looking at schools that are right for their family”.

The last application round closed in September 2016.

The government has also confirmed it will proceed with watered-down proposals for grammar school expansion.

As promised in 2016, grammar schools will be made to become more inclusive. In return, they will get access to £50 million in annual funding to expand and take more pupils. The cash part of a £200 million investment already announced by the government in 2016.

This is capital funding to create more space for pupils, but it will only be given to those schools which produce a “fair access and partnership plan”, setting out what action they will take to increase admissions of disadvantaged pupils.

The announcement was welcomed by Jim Skinner of the Grammar School Heads’ Association, who is “very pleased that, like other good and outstanding schools, selective schools now have access to a fund to allow them to expand their premises”.

But Melissa Benn, the chair of anti-selection campaign group Comprehensive Future, believes it is a “mistake” to allow existing grammar schools to expand.

“All the evidence shows that the way to create the best schools system is to phase out selection not to expand it. I think it will be taking our schools system backwards,” she said.

Latest education roles from

Level 3 Nursery Assistant

Level 3 Nursery Assistant

Reach Academy Feltham

Curriculum Manager in Sports and Public Services

Curriculum Manager in Sports and Public Services

Buckinghamshire College Group

HR Coordinator (FTC)

HR Coordinator (FTC)

Academies Enterprise Trust

Specialist Trainer Engineering: Electrical Installation or Maintenance, Instrumentation & Control or Mechanical Engineering

Specialist Trainer Engineering: Electrical Installation or Maintenance, Instrumentation & Control or Mechanical Engineering

Bridgwater & Taunton College

Course Leader Engineering Electrical Installation or Maintenance, Instrumentation & Control or Mechanical Engineering

Course Leader Engineering Electrical Installation or Maintenance, Instrumentation & Control or Mechanical Engineering

Bridgwater & Taunton College

Maths Achievement Mentor

Maths Achievement Mentor

Barnsley College

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Mark Watson

    When will anyone actually challenge this tripe that is consistently put forward by the Catholic Church – “Canon Law prevents its schools from turning away Catholic pupils”.
    It’s just so demonstrably wrong.
    Say a Catholic school has capacity for 500 pupils, and 900 Catholic children apply for places. Guess what, 400 Catholic pupils are going to be turned away.
    So what’s the difference between that and having a faith cap?
    And to squash the other false argument which is often dragged out, the way that the cap works means that pupils are NEVER turned away because of their Catholic faith. It simply means that over the cap threshold faith cannot be used as an admission criteria.

    • In fact there is nothing in Canon law that prevents the Catholic Church from opening free schools under the 50% cap – as witness the Catholic International Education Office (OIEC): ‘L’ecole catholique est une ecole inclusive…, une ecole non discriminante, ouverte a tous… est tout sauf [anything but] une ecole communautariste. Elle est ouverte a tous.’ [A Catholic school is an inclusive school… a school without discrimination, open to all… it is anything but a communitarian/sectarian school. It is open to all.” In this leaflet it then boasts of near total Muslim attendance at some schools in the way we are used to from the CofE.

      The Catholic Church here has been caught out in a failed deception of the Government. The Catholic Education Service should hang its head in shame.

      In fact 80% of the public wanted the cap to remain in place – including 67% of Catholics!

  2. Perhaps Jim Skinner of the GSHA could explain what funds for expansion were not available for grammar schools before today’s £50m bung.

    My local grammar has had a brand new technology centre and science block since it became an academy. It also increased its pupil admission number when the ink was still wet on the funding agreement. Perhaps Mr Skinner could explain where the money came from to finance this expansion if not from the DfE.