DfE’s new property group exacerbates school land sale fears

Plans to transfer ownership of all school land to the government combined with rumours surrounding a property company set up by the Department for Education (DfE) have sparked fears about a possible future sale of assets.

The government’s recent white paper sets out proposals for the transfer of school land currently held and managed by local authorities to the state when those schools become academies. The land will then be leased back to the academy sponsor, much in the same way the councils currently lease land to schools.

But the recent establishment of a “property group”, which the department claims was set up to find sites for new free schools, has raised questions about whether the land will continue to rest in public hands.

Rebecca Long-Bailey (pictured), the Labour MP for Salford and Eccles and shadow treasury minister, is among those who have drawn parallels with NHS Property Services, set up by the Department of Health in 2010 to manage land taken from primary care trusts, and whose chief executive Elaine Hewitt now sits on the DfE’s property group.

A legal source close to the DfE has told Schools Week he believes the company will eventually function in a way that facilitates the white paper policy, claiming it will “hold and manage the land under the new arrangements”.

The government has insisted the group is aimed at securing free school sites and not linked to the white paper, but has not said whether or not it will take on additional duties in future.

A spokesperson also said “clear safeguards” were in place to prevent academies selling or changing the use of public land without permission, claiming it was “disingenuous” to suggest otherwise. But she did not address fears that the government might eventually dispose of it.

Nicky Morgan, the education secretary, faced questions from Long-Bailey in parliament last Wednesday about how property would be managed once in the government’s ownership.

Long-Bailey said she “questioned the necessity” of creating a property company when the land was held by the state, adding: “It would of course make perfect sense if there was, say, a proposed sale of that property management company in the future. I say no more.”

She also sought answers about whether academy tenants would be required to seek consent for any underletting, and whether or not there would be local engagement to ensure that any tenants were “deemed beneficial to the school and the wider community, rather than simply offering a financial gain for the academy”.

Long-Bailey called the current proposals “extremely ambiguous” as they failed to clarify where proceeds of sales would be directed. She suggested they go to the relevant local authority, “so that they can be put to good and beneficial local use”.

Morgan did not respond to Long-Bailey’s questions due to the format of the debate.

The property group was announced in February as part of the release of wave 10 of successful free school bids. Members include Michael Strong, former executive chairman of CBRE Europe, Middle East and Africa, Philip Bell-Brown, group property director at Dixons Carphone, and Ric Lewis, a governor at King Solomon Academy in London and chief executive of Tristan Capital Partners.

Your thoughts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


  1. Tessa Fitzsimmons

    Well we always knew that they were gonna sell off valuable school land! Aka public property!. The conservatives are selling off everything they can to give themselves a huge profit and job prospects in the future! As they know they are not getting into power again. So they are distorying the country for another party to pick up the pieces! It’s all about the money! MPs biggest dictators of them all! But conservative MPs are worse they are slimy! Quotes like “we’re doing it for your children” yet mentel health is on the rise and academies choose high quality students and no way to complaint. “we have to pays off the the country’s debt” yet MPs got 10% pay rise when nurses got 1%. They get things payed for! And spend more on stuff we don’t need. “We’re making the nhs better” yet making doctors working longer hours, waiting list are really long you will be dead b4 u get there & less money cos all MPs need a holiday! “Staying in the EU is better” yet cameon bows down to Europe, we have no control over our own country and prisoners get the vote! Need I say more!

  2. Geoff Powers

    This is an utter and complete public scandal. The government has set itself up as a latter day robber baron, stealing public property from local authorities which has been paid for by ratepayers and council-tax payers over many, many years They’re not even taking it over while agreeing to repay the local authorities for the land and buildings. In the USA it might well be defined as grand theft. What modern legal system makes it morally right for a government to behave in this way. Worse, it is likely that academy trusts will gain the right to dispose of land and buildings acquired in this way on the open market. I don’t have the words to express the anger and disgust I feel!