The government is lobbying those in charge of controversial university technical colleges to move away from recruitment at 14, the academies minister has revealed.
Lord Agnew told the House of Lords today that he is “trying to encourage” Lord Baker, the founder of the UTC movement to “adjust the entry age of UTCs so that they are not in conflict with surrounding schools and then local areas can work in harmony with one another”.
His intervention marks a significant climb-down for the government, which until now has been hesitant to express a view either way on UTC admissions.
We are doing as much as we can. The system still needs to improve
The UTC model has been fraught with problems, largely because recruiting pupils at 14 is so difficult. Ministers and UTC architects have come under pressure to change the admissions age as more and more of the 14 to 19 institutions have failed to become financially sustainable and closed down.
Agnew did not say what the admissions age should be, but most of those lobbying for change advocate a switch from 14 to 16, a move which would bring UTCs in line with sixth forms.
Last week, the former schools minister David Laws called for a halt to the expansion of the UTCs programme, after his think tank the Education Policy Institute faulted their academic progress and ability to recruit and retain learners.
Asked in the Lords by Baker if he would “spread his enthusiasm” for UTCs amongst his colleagues in government, Agnew praised the “enormous amount of effort” put in by Baker and his organisation, the Baker Dearing Trust.
“He’s right, I have put a lot of my own time into it because I think they are a vital part of the skills network,” Agnew said.
“We are doing as much as we can. The system still needs to improve. I am encouraging the Baker Dearing Trust to allow more UTCs to join multi-academy trusts so their resources can be pooled. I’m also trying to encourage [Lord Baker] to adjust the entry age of UTCs so that they are not in conflict with surrounding schools and then local areas can work in harmony with one another.”
Baker described UTCs as “outstanding schools, some of the most successful schools in the country”, and said we “need many more of them”.
However, research by Schools Week’s sister paper FE Week found in March that more than two thirds of UTCs visited over the previous year were rated ‘requires improvement’ or ‘inadequate’ by Ofsted. None of the UTCs inspected between February 2017 and February 2018 were rated ‘outstanding’.
Since 2011, the Department for Education has allocated almost £330 million of capital spending to the UTC programme. In this time, 59 UTCs have been established, although eight of these have since closed and one converted to an academy. Another, UTC@Harbourside, will close in August 2019.