Skip to content
19 November 2026

Exclusive

DfE pondered launching in-house MIS to save schools cash

CEO of England’s largest MAT brands government's data spine plan 'an expansion of the surveillance state'
7 min read
|

Listen to this story

Members can listen to an AI-generated audio version of this article.

1.0x

Audio narration uses an AI-generated voice.

0:00 0:00

Government officials considered launching their own in-house management information system (MIS) for schools in a bid to shield them from a £200 million turf war.

This comes amid warnings leaders have been left in the dark over the Department for Education’s MIS framework and “data spine”, despite fears the “limitless” information it would transfer from schools to Whitehall could be exposed to hackers.

Jon Coles, the chief executive of the United Learning Trust, whose academy chain is the largest in England, has urged ministers to tear up the proposals – which, he said, had been drawn up “in the most covert way possible”.

Sir Jon Coles
Jon Coles

“This is quite simply the most concerning intervention by government into the running of schools I can remember.

“It is a vast expansion of the surveillance state without any rationale and would give not only this government, but every future government of whatever political party, potentially unlimited access to an unlimited amount of personal information about every child and every adult in state schools.”

Schools Week revealed in January that ministers hoped MIS providers would help them “harness the potential” of the real-time data they collected.

The following month Labour rebadged the scheme as the “data spine”.

The scheme is part of plans to create an MIS framework, which will give schools “a route to market” for the tech and enable “them to analyse, use and report on key data”.

‘This should not be rushed’

Civil servants drew up the purchasing route to shield schools from a £200 million MIS turf war, which has resulted in high-profile legal disputes that has involved some of England’s largest MATs.

But Emma Harrison, of the Association of School and College Leaders, warned that careful handling was needed to ensure the framework was workable for schools and had the confidence of the whole sector – “this is not something that should be rushed into”.

She demanded assurances over “data protection, safeguarding and what will be included within the framework”.

Coles said he feared that the scheme “would potentially give the state access to detailed information on every child in the country – every mark, every merit, every detention, absence, suspension”.

The data could extend to addresses, ages, ethnicities and the names of siblings and parents, as well details about safeguarding, medical needs, the detail of EHCP – “any issues at home or in the family that schools are aware of”.

It could also capture “similarly limitless” level of detail for staff and volunteers, he said.

Georgia Gould, the schools minister, said officials last November did a market assessment of options.

Georgia Gould

Before deciding to go ahead with the framework the following month, they also considered “developing an MIS within the department”.

Other options included “included taking no action, providing further advice and guidance for the sector, introducing accreditation or certification, conducting an open procurement for a single MIS for the whole sector”.

The government has not said why it ruled out creating its own system in-house.

Primary objective

Gould said the primary objective of the framework was to tackle poor supplier behaviour and provide benefits such as more balanced terms and conditions, easier moves to new suppliers, better price transparency and better value for money.

However, leaders fear the government’s consultation on the proposals hasn’t been broad enough.

Documents show the DfE’s sector engagement for the MIS framework involved more than 50 “interviews” with individual schools, academy trusts and local authorities.

It later created a “working group” with eight academies – rather than academy trusts – and five council-maintained school representatives.

Coles attacked the consultation for being conducted “in the most covert way possible”, leaving most school and trust leaders with no idea that it was underway.

Harrison said her union would also welcome more widespread engagement as the process developed.

Academy trusts will have to ensure their contracts are aligned with the MIS framework – which has not been published yet – by September next year. From that point, they will have to use the framework to secure their next full-term deal.

If a contract expires before September 2027, any extension or replacement must be for no more than 12 months and “act as a transitional arrangement ahead of framework procurement”.

‘Cart before the horse’

Samira Sadeghi, of the Confederation of School Trusts, said school leaders were having to plan around a framework that had not yet been published and a data spine whose scope and governance remained unclear.

“That risks putting the cart before the horse.”

Samira Sadeghi

James Browning, chief operating officer for Lift Schools, whose organisation runs 62 schools, thinks the data spine “has real potential – especially so if it reduces repeated requests for information and gives leaders useful insights”.

But he called for “greater clarity” on how the information gathered would be used.

Sadeghi said questions remained over what trusts “will be required to do, what data will be shared and why, who will have access to it, and how it will be protected”.

“And the sector needs a meaningful opportunity to shape these arrangements before they are fixed.”

The government has also told council-maintained schools that they are expected to use the MIS purchasing route.

Gould said the framework would be “refreshed annually, with no limit on the number of suppliers appointed”. She said this would “promote competition and encourage economic growth in the market”.

Security concerns

Coles said there was no explanation of how this “dragnet approach” would benefit pupils or adults. Nothing has been put forward to outline why a “less draconian” approach could not be used.

One policy expert, who helped to draw up the white paper and asked not to be named, also doubted the data spine could be readied in time for next year.

“I am worried that through this rushed or ham-fisted approach they could inadvertently screw up the whole thing. They appear to be sneaking this through the MIS framework.

“This is a lot of student data that is going to be moved from MIS into some kind of central DfE receptacle. I think parents will want to know what’s being planned.”

The white paper said the data spine would “create a secure, privacy-respecting and streamlined way” to share information – such as pupil records and attendance, progress and assessments figures.

Coles said the DfE had “an extremely poor” record of data protection, and had been hacked more than once.

It had also said it might share information with other agencies – “law enforcement agencies might have access to behaviour and attendance records”.

Deal withdrawn

In 2016, Schools Week reported that the DfE had signed a secret deal with the Home Office to share data on pupils’ nationality and country of birth to be used for immigration enforcement. The deal was withdrawn after a widespread boycott by schools.

Four years later, The Sunday Times uncovered a company providing age-verification services for gambling companies had been wrongly provided access to an education database containing the information of 28 million children.

And in July, the names and contact details of school leaders were among more than 600,000 records stolen by hackers in a cyber-attack targeting the DfE’s help portal and Turing Scheme database.

The DfE has been “working on several proof-of-concepts” for the data spine. Despite pausing these activities, it stressed the programme would continue, with an announcement expected this autumn.

Law firm Browne Jacobson previously labelled the project one of the government’s “most ambitious” proposals – but warned that was “precisely where the risk lies”.

Coles urged ministers to “put a stop to it and make clear that there will be proper consultation and discussion with schools … for proportionate data collection”.

“If they do not do so, MIS providers should be clear that they will not sign up to the plan. School leaders should seek confirmation from their MIS provider that they will not do so.”

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news