Listen to this story Members can listen to an AI-generated audio version of this article. 1.0x Audio narration uses an AI-generated voice. 0:00 0:00 Become a member to listen to this article Subscribe An academy trust boss has urged leaders to “speak honestly” and “without fear” about problems with the inspection regime. Lincoln Anglican Academy Trust (LAAT), which runs 24 primaries and secondaries across Lincolnshire, has been through six full inspections and two monitoring visits at a seventh school since Ofsted launched its new framework late last year. In an open letter calling out inconsistencies with the watchdog’s framework, Jackie Waters-Dewhurst, the trust’s chief executive, said she was “increasingly concerned about the processes’ consistency and the experience of those being inspected”. Independent research by IFF Research, commissioned by Ofsted, found most education providers felt the new-style inspections were “collaborative”. Sixty-nine per cent of schools agreed inspectors “worked collaboratively with them to identify areas for development or priorities for improvement”. But Waters-Dewhurst said “experienced educationists feel that they are fighting for two days simply to be heard”. She urged “headteachers, governors, trusts and those who care about education to come together and speak honestly about what is working and what is not. “We should be able to challenge the system without fear, share our experiences without worrying about consequences, and demand an inspection process that is rigorous without being unnecessarily adversarial.” Impact on wellbeing It comes amid backlash from unions about the ongoing impact of inspections on leader and teacher wellbeing. Lucy Powell, the education secretary, is expected to make changes in the coming months. When Ofsted launched its new framework it took steps to improve consistency of inspections, creating an “internal consistency improvement hub” and ramping up quality assurance visits. It also introduced HMI-led inspections and “better matching of Ofsted inspectors’ backgrounds” to the settings they inspected. But Waters-Dewhurst said LAAT had found the application of the new framework “can vary considerably”. “Too often, the experience of an inspection seems to depend on the individual inspector’s interpretation and professional lens.” The five LAAT schools for which reports have been published mostly received ‘expected standard’ grades, and some ‘needs attention’. One school was described as requiring significant improvement after receiving two ‘urgent improvement’ grades, as well as ‘needs attention’ and ‘expected standard’. Waters-Dewhurst said LAAT had “experienced almost every possible approach” to inspecting governance – from inspectors wanting to see the chair of governors alone, wanting to meet with trust leaders, directors and governors together, and local governance “not being explored at all”. She also reported wide variation in how inspectors “interpret the extent to which a trust should be examined as…responsible for a school”. The involvement of central trust staff in inspection had also been variously “refused, welcomed or limited”. Quality assurance concerns LAAT’s letter also tabled concerns about the watchdog’s quality assurance process – which includes on-site checks on inspectors’ work carried out during a sample of inspections. Three of the trust’s inspections have been through these checks, Waters-Dewhurst said. She added that while this was supposed to focus on the lead inspector and inspection team, the process “changes the dynamic” with the school “becoming the collateral damage”. “Quality assured inspections are always harder,” she said. “The lead inspector becomes less nuanced, less relaxed, and more intense.” She also raised the example of an HMI taking part on the first day of a school’s inspection then returning the next day to quality assure it. LAAT challenged this at the time, but Ofsted did not deem it a conflict of interest. According to IFF Research, 65 per cent of schools, including 47 per cent of secondaries, said inspectors sought to understand and take account of their setting’s unique context – an area in which chief inspector Martyn Oliver has acknowledged Ofsted “must do more”. Waters-Dewhurst said the new framework “places considerable emphasis on understanding a school’s context”, yet in some inspections there was “a refusal to look at anything beyond” the school’s data. Emotional toll Waters-Dewhurst said that in most cases inspectors’ final judgments were the same as LAAT’s self-evaluations. LAAT’s concerns did not relate to individual grades or report cards. Her chief concern was around the emotional toll of the process on leaders and trust teams. The atmosphere of inspections often felt “unnecessarily adversarial”. “There is nothing wrong… with challenge, but challenge does not have to mean confrontation, and accountability does not have to mean creating an environment in which experienced educationists feel that they are fighting for two days simply to be heard,” she wrote. “You come out of an inspection having questioned your decisions, your leadership, and at times your ability to carry on.” IFF Research found 88 per cent of 250 schools reported their inspection had negatively affected their or their staff’s wellbeing. Half reported it was negatively affected “a lot” or “a fair amount”. Waters-Dewhurst stressed meaningful accountability was needed, but called on Ofsted to “listen, reflect, and change”. Powell told Sky News last week she wants to see changes to the inspectorate’s “culture and approach”, as well as its framework. But Waters-Dewhurst said the changes “should be about more than refining the wording of a framework” and should examine “how the framework is interpreted and experienced by the people who work in our schools and trusts”. An Ofsted spokesperson said: “We take all feedback seriously and are committed to learning from it. We are working closely with the Department for Education, and listening to both parents and professionals, as we continue to improve inspections.”