Skip to content
19 November 2026

Exclusive

‘Two tier’ free school meals system risks ‘holiday hunger’, experts warn

Government ignores pleas to extend holiday programme to 500,000 children newly eligible for free school meals

Lydia Chantler-Hicks

More from this author
5 min read
|
Schoolgirls having lunch in the cafeteria at school

Listen to this story

Members can listen to an AI-generated audio version of this article.

1.0x

Audio narration uses an AI-generated voice.

0:00 0:00

Failing to fund holiday meals and activities for thousands of children newly eligible for free school meals risks creating a “two-tier” system that could penalise working families, campaigners have warned.

As of September, all pupils from households receiving universal credit are eligible for free meals. An earnings threshold previously applied.

The government said it expected 500,000 more children to become eligible, helping “lift approximately 100,000 children out of poverty by the end of this parliament”.

But while children on the “expanded” entitlement receive lunches during term-time, they do not attract the same provision as those receiving the standard, “targeted” free school meals.

“Targeted” free school meals are for children from households with earnings of £7,400 or less.

They attract a range of extra funding benefits, including pupil premium cash for their schools and HAF funding.

Experts say this “has created a two-tier system” that could lead to “holiday hunger” for children newly receiving free meals or who have moved from the “targeted” to “expanded” entitlement.

They have written to the prime minister and education secretary making an “urgent call” to “maintain the link between free school meal entitlement and the HAF programme”.

Experts had also hoped the government would use Wednesday’s budget to allocate extra funding to extend the holiday activities and food (HAF) programme to all pupils eligible for free school meals, but no cash emerged.

‘Unjust’

The government website describes the HAF programme as providing “healthy meals, enriching activities, and free childcare places” to eligible children, “benefiting their health, wellbeing and learning”.

In their letter to Andy Burnham and Lucy Powell, experts said they were deeply concerned that children eligible for free meals during term time would not be eligible for the HAF programme and called for change.

The letter was co-signed by Greta Defeyter, the dean of social mobility policy engagement at Northumbria University and chair of Feeding Britain, Andrew Forsey, the chief executive of Feeding Britain, Paul and Anja Wright, the chief executives of Alliance 4 Children, and Labour MP Sharon Hodgson, chair of the all-party parliamentary group on school food.

They said having “acknowledged the acute need” to provide meals to children during term time, “it is unjust to conclude that this need simply vanishes during the school holidays”.

They warned the move “risks undoing the developmental and nutritional gains accrued during term time and threatens to inflict significant hardship on poorer working families”.

Ring-fenced HAF funding is distributed centrally to councils.

The scheme is aimed at children receiving free school meals, though the government allows town halls to use up to 15 per cent of funding to offer free or subsidised holiday club places to other children who “could benefit from HAF”.

A recent Parentkind survey found more than half of parents find the school holidays financially difficult.

Return of hunger

Defeyter warned: “By not expanding HAF eligibility … the government has created a two-tier system in which children are deemed poor enough to need a FSM during term time but not during the school holidays.

“This approach is undoubtedly going to see a return of holiday hunger.”

Since 2018, “transitional protections” put in place for families on universal credit meant pupils continued to be eligible for free school meals until the end of their school phase, even if their household income rose.

But these protections ended in September to coincide with the expansion of free school meals.

The government believed most of those on transitional protections would continue to receive free school meals because their families would still be receiving universal credit.

However, pupils transitioning from the “targeted” to “expanded” cohorts no longer attracted HAF funding.

Forsey said: “The movement of children from one category of free school meal eligibility, to another, should not disguise the fact that they are still likely to be living in, or on the fringes of, poverty.

“How can the government acknowledge that children require help with meals in term-time, but not in the holidays?”

Eligibility checks

There is no national data yet available on how many children are now eligible for expanded or targeted free school meals.

Schools have been carrying out eligibility checks ahead of the October census. This data is expected in June.

The threshold for “targeted” FSM has remained at £7,400 for eight-and-a-half years.

In that same period, consumer price inflation has soared 36.7 per cent. Had it risen in line with general inflation, it would today be around £10,120.

In their letter, the campaigners said this eligibility threshold “severely penalise[s] working families”.

“A household earning just slightly over the £7,400 limit is deemed ineligible, yet their income is entirely absorbed by rent, energy, and everyday essentials,” they said.

“These families have no disposable income for holiday childcare”.

School food campaigner Andy Jolley said not providing holiday help “seem[s] contradictory to the government’s expressed aim of supporting families”.

“On the one hand they’re expanding breakfast clubs, promoting free universal childcare, on the other, they’re reducing the number of poorer households supported during the holidays.”

Holidays ‘financially difficult’

Frank Young, the chief executive of Parentkind, said parents were being squeezed from every direction. “The bills do not stop when the school gates close.”

“These pressures reach well beyond the poorest families. We need to take the cost of the school holidays seriously when so many parents are struggling to make the sums add up.”

Jolley said the numbers transitioning into expanded free school meals, or losing their entitlement, would be felt further down the line if pupil premium funding was reduced.

“It will have a significant ongoing impact on school finances” he said. However, he stressed this would not happen “overnight”.

For pupils who lose free school meals eligibility entirely, the so-called “ever6” rule means they continue attracting pupil premium funding for six years. But this rule does also not apply to HAF funding.

The Department for Education did not respond to requests for comment.

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news