Skip to content
20 November 2026

DfE to clarify work experience guidance after confusion

New guidance left schools uncertain over whether work placements for under 16s would require DBS checks

Esmé Kenney

More from this author
7 min read
|

Listen to this story

Members can listen to an AI-generated audio version of this article.

1.0x

Audio narration uses an AI-generated voice.

0:00 0:00

Ministers plan to clarify guidance on work experience after schools and employers were left “scratching their heads” over whether they will need to seek DBS checks for staff hosting placements.

New keeping children safe in education guidance states that offering “teaching, training, instruction or care or supervision” for work placements for under 16s “frequently” or for longer than three days in a thirty-day period counts as “regulated activity”.

Those supervising work placements were previously exempt, but this changed following the passage of the Crime and Policing Act, which came into force last month.

The safeguarding guidance does not explicitly state that DBS checks are needed, but instead says schools “must not allow someone on the barred list” to take part.

Schools warn they feel uncertain about how to interpret the guidance, and fear small businesses will withdraw from offering placements due to the extra administrative burden of checks.

It comes as the government announced it would create 200,000 placements for 14 to 16-year-olds as part of their “national mission on work experience”.

A Department for Education spokesperson said the changes will “make sure individuals who regularly work with children can be subject to checks, where appropriate”.

“We have however heard from the sector that in some cases there is uncertainty around making the determination of when DBS is appropriate.

“We will continue to work with the sector to clarify what this new guidance means for them.”

The Careers and Enterprise Company (CEC) said it was in “regular contact with government officials to clarify what the changes will mean for schools and employers offering work experience”.

Work experience provider Unifrog has written to the DfE to raise potential legal issues with the guidance itself.

The government expects schools to arrange two weeks’ worth of work experience for every pupil over the course of their secondary education.

This includes a new requirement for a week of work experience activities in years 7 to 9 on top of the traditional week in years 10 to 11.

Further barriers

Karen Hayward, executive principal of Sandy Secondary School in Bedfordshire, said: “Currently, we successfully secure work shadowing placements for approximately 90 per cent of our year 10 cohort, something we are incredibly proud of.

“However, I am genuinely concerned that the additional requirements and uncertainty surrounding DBS checks could significantly reduce this figure in future years.”

Hayward said the school already follows “a very robust protocol to ensure placements are appropriate and students are safeguarded”, which has “not routinely required DBS checks” until now.

She was concerned it could create “further barriers” for employers.

“We have worked incredibly hard to build relationships with local employers and create opportunities that broaden our students’ horizons.

“It would be deeply disappointing to see those opportunities diminish because businesses feel that the process has become too complicated, costly or burdensome.”

She also warned the changes “could disproportionately affect the very students who stand to benefit most from work experience, particularly those from disadvantaged backgrounds who may not have family connections or access to professional networks”.

Alex Kelly, co-founder at Unifrog, said the company had seen a 37 per cent drop in work experience placements, from 644 last September to 408 this September.

“We think that’s just an early warning, because actually September is when a tiny proportion of placements get given the green light to go ahead.

“We think we’re just seeing the beginnings of a massive cliff drop of year 10 placements.

“Small and medium- size employers are going to be the ones that are really caught by this, because they don’t have the bandwidth to run checks.”

The change has also prompted concern at the charity Futures for All, formerly Speakers for Schools, which also organises work placements.

‘Chilling effect’

Nick Brook, the charity’s chief executive officer, said schools had been left “scratching their heads” over the guidance and fears it could have a “chilling effect”.

He is concerned that employers may opt for placements that are shorter than three days, so they do not need to get DBS checks, which means pupils end up with placements that are “shorter, less beneficial, less meaningful experiences for young people”.

The DfE should confirm whether staff supervising placements could be classed as volunteers, meaning the DBS checks would be free for them, Brook added.

“The most pressing thing here is that we get some clear employer friendly guidance, so that everyone can be reassured and have clarity as to what everyone needs to do.”

Su Pickerill, head of social value at construction firm Wates Group, said: “Everyone agrees that safeguarding must come first, but the change in supervision exemption has made it more complicated to navigate, and potentially more costly.

“We have a dedicated team, so we’ll make it work, but there’s a risk that the goodwill of some employers will be lost, particularly with opportunities for under 16s, because it’s becomes too difficult to do the right thing.”

Experts question definition

“Regulated activity” was first defined in the Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups Act 2006 as “any form of teaching, training or instruction of children”.

But this does not include “teaching, training or instruction provided to a child in the course of his employment”, unless the child is both under 16 and the activity is “carried out by a person in respect of whom arrangements exist principally for that purpose” – in other words, the whole purpose of their job is to supervise people on work experience.

Dai Durbridge, partner in the education team at law firm Browne Jacobson, said: “The term employment is not defined in the act, and you can easily run the argument either way.

“There’s clearly an argument that work experience is not employment…in which case, it’s regulated activity.”

The vetting and barring scheme non-statutory guidance, published in 2010, said any supervision provided “as part of the employment of a child under the age of 16 (which may be part of their learning or in a work experience situation) is not regulated activity if carried out by a person for whom arrangements do not exist principally for that purpose”.

The Crime and Policing Act, which came into force in September, removed the “supervision exemption”, which had meant that something that could otherwise be deemed regulated activity would not be classed as this, as long as it was supervised by someone who was in regulated activity, such as a teacher.

The keeping children safe in education guidance was amended to align with the act.

It states: “If the person providing the teaching, training, instruction or care or supervision to the child on a work experience placement or activity will be doing so frequently or for more than three days in a 30-day period, or overnight, this is a regulated activity.

“You must not allow someone on the barred list to take part in regulated activity.”

It does state that other individuals in the workplace who are not involved in overseeing the work experience placement are not in regulated activity, and that DBS checks are not required for staff supervising 16- or 17-year-olds on work experience.

But the new guidance does mean 16 and 17-year-olds who do work experience in a school or sixth form where they may come into contact with children may be considered to be in regulated activity.

It adds that in these cases, the work experience provider, such as the sixth form, “should consider whether a DBS enhanced check should be requested for the child in question”.

Durbridge added: “Rightly or wrongly, the DfE must have made a decision that work experience is regulated activity”.

He said it would be “sensible” for the DfE to confirm whether work experience is classed as employment.

“It’s causing experts in the area to question whether the DfE intended to class work experience as regulated activity or not.”

The Disclosure and Barring Service said there was currently “no evidence that the removal of the supervision exemption has materially affected DBS check volumes or resourcing”, adding that it would continue to be monitored and resourced appropriately.

Share

Explore more on these topics

No Comments

More from this topic

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news