Skip to content
18 November 2026

Pupils using AI to do coursework are cheating themselves

We must get the message to students that they risk trading a short-term grade for a longer-term gap
Ian Bauckham Guest Contributor

Chief regulator, Ofqual

4 min read
|

The best part of my job is the chance to visit schools and colleges up and down the country.

There is one topic that is raised on almost every visit: the impact of AI on the classroom and more particularly for me, as chief regulator at Ofqual, the impact on exams and assessments.

The area which causes us all the most concern is coursework based on unsupervised extended writing. On this, teachers all tell the same story.

In subjects where this kind of coursework still exists, like A-level English and history, teachers now need to monitor coursework handed to them for signs of uncharacteristic writing styles or unexpected increased quality.

Another increasingly common tell-tale sign is submissions that are much longer than might have been anticipated. This places an additional workload burden on teachers.

This review burden comes alongside an ethical one. When do you refer a piece of coursework to the exam board because you suspect undeclared AI use?

Sometimes it is clear, but on other occasions it is in the grey zone. In this grey zone, it is worth remembering what is at stake.

A level playing field

Getting good grades only counts if they are achieved fairly, on a level playing field with other students.

Where a qualification comes with extended writing coursework, it is intended to demonstrate that a student knows about the topic in question, has developed their research skills and honed their arguments.

Coursework exists to build skills that only get built by doing the work: researching, structuring an argument, drafting, redrafting, getting something wrong and fixing it.

When a student uses AI to produce coursework, they trade a short-term grade for a longer-term gap.

The vast majority of teachers who teach subjects with coursework already feel confident having a direct conversation with a student about their use of AI. I know that is not always easy, but we must thank teachers for their professionalism.

Follow the guidance

So if you are suspicious about a student’s work handed to you as coursework, follow the exam board’s guidance and refer it for investigation.

That is the only way we can maintain fairness and integrity while this sort of coursework is still being used. With the support of your school, college and its leadership, you are helping to protect the integrity both of learning and of qualifications.

The alternative is that a grade becomes like a medal for running a marathon in two hours when the runner got a lift in a car. It is hollow, meaningless and ultimately fraudulent.

The gap between what the grade says a student can do and what they can actually do does not disappear.

It resurfaces later, perhaps at A-level, at university, in an apprenticeship, or even in a job, at a moment the student didn’t choose and often can’t recover from easily.

That is the real cost of AI misuse, and it falls on exactly the young person the system is meant to serve.

Not a theoretical risk

This is not a theoretical risk.

A recent paper by Strömberg, Lei and Wu, The generative AI learning penalty: Evidence from Chinese secondary education, followed more than 26,000 students over 30 months.

Their homework scores rose after they started using AI tools, but their closed-book exam scores fell by around 20 per cent within six months, and the more they used AI, the bigger the fall.

The researchers concluded that students with the biggest falls in scores were outsourcing the work, so the practice that builds understanding never happened. This should be a wake-up call to anyone who thinks undiscriminating AI use by students is ok.

We’ve produced a toolkit, including a lesson plan, a classroom poster, an assembly presentation and a briefing note for senior leaders to support this.

They have been designed to be used without adaptation, because we know teachers’ time is already stretched. Use the resources as appropriate for your context. The important thing is to get the message across to students and remain vigilant for signs of AI misuse.

Every student who uses AI to shortcut their coursework is not getting away with something.

They are quietly losing something, hollowing out the value both of their learning and their qualification, and most of them don’t yet know it. We must relentlessly challenge any assumption that this is acceptable.

Share

No Comments

Featured jobs from FE Week jobs / Schools Week jobs

Browse more news